Thanks for taking the time to reply.
In line with the answers you've just given, could you now answer the following:
[1] If, as you both seem to agree, the 'remnant' of 'anointed ones' are all part of the 'Faithful and Discreet Slave class', how then do they fulfill Jesus commission to 'feed his household meat in due season' unless they are a part of the 'Governing Body'?
[2] If, as you state,
the Governing Body [are] more or less an administrative unit representing this group [the remnant]
how do they recive input from these anointed ones scattered throughout the Earth so as to represent them?
[3] If in the few congregations where there exist cogent members of the anointed remnant of the Faithful and Discrete slave class, would it not be reasonable to expect that those ones would be taking the lead in the teaching and spritual feeding in those localities?
OldHippie, you aren't necessarily gullible and I'm certainly not trying to get you mired in some theological pit. It's just that these sorts of questions were the ones that first started to make me think for myself.
I sure don't have all the answers, but when it appeared to me that doctrines I once supported had become unsupportable I knew I had to make some serious choices.
I didn't want be df'd for the sake of my family and friends. I couldn't disassociate for the same reason and yet I needed to keep my personal integrity.
Like many thousands of others I became a 'Nominal JW'.
Perhaps this is a form of hypocrisy - I'm still struggling to exist this way - but the alternative is too awful to contemplate, the loss of my Mother, sisters, brother, aunts, uncles, cousins and many, many dear friends.
The questions I posed in this thread are not the sorts of things that most JW's spend any time worrying over but that doesn't mean that they are unimportant.
If these questions cannot be answered convincingly what does that say for the validity of the Watchtowers claims for itself?
"Read not to contradict and confute, nor to believe and take for granted, nor to find talk or discourse, but to weigh and consider." --Francis Bacon
. http://jw.escape.to