If it turns out that this situation never gets corroborated and stays in the realm of hearsay, how is it that Bill's reputation will be damaged by his simply asking for information?
By asking such a sensational question, he is spreading details of a salacious rumor. If it (more than likely) turns out to be false, or greatly exaggerated, Bill has shown himself to be gullible, and over eager to believe ill of JWs. This hurts his credibility when representing Silentlambs.
If he was looking for confirmation, he could have asked far more discreetly ("Anyone hear any rumors about Billings? Email me.").
By the way, Eric, have you stopped beating your wife yet?