Check an earlier thread about this film from folks who appreciated it's reality.[post:667305]
The Five Points in NewYork were brutal and filthy. The film, rather than exaggerating deemphasized the true violent reality. The riot happened. The military did just what you saw them doing. The gangs were real. Even many of the main characters (not DiCaprio) were real living scum buckets. Even the firemen clubs were real. There's plenty of history written about the 19th century in NewYork.
Plmkzy : I am so in agreement with you. This film and Daniel Day Lewis should have won academy awards. I mean this guy never got out of character.
Many murders went unsolved because no one cared about the poor. Prostitution was something most women did to make enough money to eat. Many women were abandoned with children. Many children were abandoned by parents. This is what the good old days were really all about.
An excellent novel (Written by a historian) is "the Alienist" give it a try.