This post made me recall a shepherding call I was asked to do with another elder.
This couple in their 40's had three children and seemed to be in love with each other and had a good family.
They told us that they had an argument and the wife had slapped her husband. They seemed to be unwilling to tell us what the start of all this was. Just that they were angry and unhappy with each other.
The elder with me started throwing bible quotes at them about a womans place and how jah hates family arguments and on and on.
I could not think of a useful scripture to use. Probably because I did not trust or like what the bible had to say about this sort of situation and the treatment of women.
So I began to take them back to the time when they married and how they felt and about the births of their children and their previous and current life and the happy times and how to not let arguments ruin an other wise happy family. I dwelt quite a bit about the children and the love and happiness that just waits for them if they solve this angry time and get on with their lives.
I began to see a change of attitude in them both but more so with the wife. I totally left the bible and the religion and its rules out of my discussion.
I was chastised by the elders for not being bible oriented. However it seemed to have solved their problem.
A few months later the husband told me that the argument they had was that she had seen another elder insult and belittle her husband and she was angry at both of them, especially at her husband because he did nothing to defend himself. During this argument she had slapped her husband.
I can vouch for her that this elder is one of the most overbearing fools I have encountered during my trials with the jw's
The husband thanked me and I noticed that his wife was more and more nice to me and seemed to be grateful. Then one day she told me that I had saved their marriage. That is how upset she was with this other elder and the one who had come with me. As the full blame was put upon her as she saw it and I blamed no one.
Recently about 2 years ago my daughter that still goes to that K dum Hall tells me that this sister told her how much she missed me, as I was one of the good elders.
Yet she, now a widow with one df'd son is still a jw in good standing . She was and is a beautiful and intelligent person.
Why throw the bible and jw rules, when some common sense discussion can be more helpful??
Outoftheorg