I liked refiners wife’s comments particularly because it seems like any movie from the U.S. with “heaps of violence” (i.e. it Pulp Fiction or The Godfather) gets really popular overseas… As for Equus I did read the play in Junior high and found the effect quite disturbing…
Bitter Mango mentioned The Magnificent Ambersons, which I love particularly because of the “commupance”. It also shows what happens to any clan of individuals who make a stern effort to isolate themselves from society (i.e. Jehovah’s Witnesses) She also liked Chasing Amy which is one of the best romance movies I have seen.
Bboyneko mentioned Dark City, which came out around the same time as The Matrix, although I consider the former a 100 times better. Seriously, one of the best sci-fi movies ever made.
Gilwarrior mentioned Red Rock West, which was shot right in my home state. I have not seen it so if it is good I’ll look for it.
Joelbear mentioned The Wizard of Oz as on of his favorites even though I’m not a huge fan. He also said I should lose my “gay card” for not mentioning it even though I was in the school play!
Ashitaka’s choices impress the hell out of me because Miller’s Crossing was also mentioned. Seriously, when I think of perfection, I think of this movie: the acting, dialogue, music, and photography are beyond reproach. I like the Seven Samurai mention although I prefer Yojimbo (Toshiro Mifune rocks).
I appreciated MegaDude’s mention of The Last Temptation of Christ because it is the best Hollywood film to analyze the life of Christ and all the ambiguities surrounding his divinity and life. If you haven’t seen I hope you do, it’s an amazing film.
Mindfield mentioned The Matrix, and I’m probably the only person who thinks it’s overrated. I prefer the Wachowski brothers’ previous effort Bound.
I liked Lilacs choices as well. I was impressed with The Green Mile particularly because it took its time with developing the characters, and I thought I wouldn’t like it….
California Sunshine mentioned the only film on the thread I have not heard of (The Enchanted Cottage) and The Godfather Series. The Godfather was the first R-rated film that I rented after I left my congregation and I was amazed at how perfect it is.
In short, excellent choices guys…