WhyNot? Your post is hard for me to read.
I only know Witnesses. I've never been one. Only recently have I gone to a meeting. I had to sneak into one in a different area of town with a stranger (who I now consider a friend) because of potential ramifications of going with my Witness friends to their congregations. If that sounds right to you, I can only pray for you.
I'm what you call a worldly.
I'm a college educated female.
I'm going on twenty years at one job. I'm a consultant for the state police and a landlord.
I don't have a tattoo.
I'm not promiscuous and never have been. I'm not even sexually active. I'm in my 40's.
I can probably count the number of times on one hand that I've had more than three glasses of wine. Wine makes me sleep. So much for partying.
I dont' smoke. Anything. I never have smoked.
I've made dumb decisions and smart decisions. We all have. It's part of growing. I do not believe God hates me because of my dumb ones.
I don't like bars, clubs or parties. Never have. I'm an extrovert but not my thing.
I have a 21 year old daughter - to my husband at that time. I'm now divorced. I was the first divorcee in my family in my lifetime.
He was abusive. God didn't introduce me to him because of a hatred for any former life decisions. I was put in his life to show him what unconditional love was, but my purpose was very obviously not to stay. I still feel sorry for him.
The Catholic church helped me regain my footing. I'm not, never have been, and most likely will never be Catholic. It was okay. They didn't ask or require that of me.
My daughter attended an independent school not because we're rich but because we were blessed. Tuition was $25,000/year - Her scholarship covered a good bit.
She was known as "Designated xxxx" not because she had a license to drive - she didn't. She was taught not to judge BUT to set parameters and require that others respect those parameters while remaining unoffensive. She does so with ease not because I trained her, but because she was given free reign to practice and perfect the skill.
She has no tattoos.
She does not smoke. Anything.
She sings jazz and works for Apple.
Both she and I have acquired friends of the same mold as us. You know what they say about birds of a certain feather...
My JW friends? I LOVE them and would do anything to help them - especially knowing what I've learned on here. Their profiles? Lovingly and respectfully - We're talking criminal record histories, depression, anxiety, legal challenges, drug and alcohol use and secret lives that they can only share with me because they know they'll be accepted unconditionally. WhyNot? I'm not talking about something I've HEARD, I'm talking about things I KNOW. I see more dysfunction in their families than I've EVER seen in the lives of those I've spent a lifetime getting to know here in the "world."
Ask yourself this. If I thought as you did, what conclusions might I draw about my kid hanging out with Witness children?
When I was young, I went to a school that was primarily the dominant culture (white) and my father was criticized by some for sending me to the school for I'd run the risk of losing my identity. His attitude? ... "She's going to have to learn how to navigate society being who she is. She may as well learn early." In my opinion, I'd put the Watchtower's stereotype down, learn how to navigate the world and teach/show your kids how to do the same.
Either decision you make, I'll still be JWN friends with you. :)