S and R, I appreciate your expertise. This was the doctrine that woke me up. I feel that not only the convaluded policy, but the enforcement of that policy through shunning despite what someones conscience may actually believe, is the most indefensible doctrine JW's ascribe to.
I recently had a discussion with an elder, and I broke down A LOT of information for him regarding blood. Key points such as albumin allowed, and white blood cells forbiden even though albumin was less of a fraction by % than white blood cells. Its just made up. His replay (after a couple months), was that JW's were teaching the truth because now everyone knows blood is dangerous.
Good Lord.
So the truth is, after all the research i have done, i would absolutely prefer cell saver technology and not to have to use someone elses blood. i think in fact that is healthier for you IF YOU HAVE THE CHOICE. But in triage when you are loosing blood exponentially, and no amount of volume expander will do what blood naturally does, which is to carry the oxygen your body needs to survive from your lungs to your organs, you have no other alternatives. Otherwise, nobody in the modern world would die from blood loss, which still happens every day. Even moreson in countries that do not have sophistacated medical systems and the expensive equipment neccesary to accomplish these feats.
Hemopure I believe is only legal in South Africa currently? This myth has made its way around the congregations that there are other things you can do. They are essentially being taught to question their doctors.
Questioning your doctor....not always a bad thing. Blood is not a perfect system, there is a profit motive, and people have their hands dirty there as well. But in the absence of a perfect system, or at least a super clear scriptural directive, a JW has to be able to follow their conscience without fear that God will then kill them for their decision.