According to Lloyd himself, copyrights can only be breached if you are selling it for profit.
This is not correct.
That's like saying it's okay for me to take someone else's personal belongings and give them away just as long as I don't sell them for a profit. Most people are smart enough to recognize this is stealing!
Theft is theft. What a thief does after they take something that doesn't belong to them changes nothing.
The intricacies of copyright law can be complex and difficult for non-attorneys to comprehend, but the basic principles are simple: If it's not yours, you cannot redistribute it in any way, shape or form. Whether or not money is involved in the transaction is frankly irrelevant.
I've come to believe that most people that claim they don't understand copyright law are dishonest and just want to violate it.
Interestingly, as with Mr. Evans currently, when it comes to their own copyrights those same people suddenly become "experts" on the subject.