I couldn't agree more with what seattleniceguy said.
I think it's deplorable that this sort of thing would come up at the book study of all places!! Aren't the elders supposed to discourage speculation about why members may have left?? And this dickhead is using abusing his authority as bookstudy conductor to *encourage open speculation* about that very subject, in a public forum? In front of your mom, to whom the elders should be giving support (their own brand of 'support', anyways)?
Not only are they encouraging speculation, I agree with whomever said that they are trying to instill fear in the masses to "examine their own spirituality" so that they, too, are not overcome by whatever it was that led astray poor Brother Minimus and his family.
ACK. The whole situation is unconscionable.