I've been wondering about this matter myself. Are there any elders/former elders posting here who might enlighten me as to just what it is that is contained in those publisher records - especially what is passed on when one transfers to a different congregation? If I am a witness in "good standing" who chooses to switch congregations for personal reasons - possibly due to a personality clash or difference of opinion with one or more of the elders in the former congregation - is this likely to be mentioned to the new elders? Is the letter they write to the new congregation simply one of introduction, stating, yes, he/she is a witness in good standing and here is his/her publisher card - or does it get into personality, perceived weaknesses or areas in need of improvement ... Just how much do these new elders know about me?
It certainly wouldn't be fair to carry with me throughout eternity the baggage and labels placed on me by some biased, imperfect individual who fancies himself a flawless judge of the human character. Just what is in those records???