Hi there, I can relate to your situation very much. After 2 years of frustration, I recently (30 days ago) ended all contact with my now ex-JW BF. I also told him I thought it was a 'cult', only difference is I did it very early on in our relationship. Sounds like you have been pretty respectful. I regret saying 'cult' as strongly as I did, only because I think it ended all reasonable conversation between he and I on this religion. He knew where I stood and was leary of talking about it with me at all. In hindsight, I wish I'd have asked more questions and tried to get him to see for himself all the inconsistencies. And had I asked questions I might have understood more about how deeply insidious these beliefs are in all aspects of a JWs life. Unfortunately, I've really been learning now, from people on this site, how messed up it is.
With all that being said, I think trying to get someone out can be a usless battle for a worldly person that's fighting alone against family and other JWs who will reinforce you as being evil. And do you really want to be married to someone who thinks you will die at Armageddon while he goes on to live in paradise? Talk about inequality - lol. I think this dynamic would damper any relationship.
It's tough. This Christmas wasn't a lot of fun being alone with all my family. Although I realized I would have been alone even if we were together since it's evil Christmas time and all, he wouldn't have joined in. We talked about this at length before.
OH, and nobody knows about me which yes, I'm insulted by...
This part is total BS! Don't be insulted, be outraged. Are you not good enough to be known? And he claims he will marry you?! I experienced that too and my anonyminity from his JW life was the final straw. It just sucks. Do you really want to be married to a man who thinks it acceptable to keep you a secret? I want a man who has some integrity and character and will stand up for me, not hide me. Such BS.
I wish you all the best with this and I hope he mans up and leaves the JWs for good, although it doesn't sound like he's anywhere near that. :(
Good luck to you.