no offense, but i have as much respect for history books and historians as some people on jwd have for the watchtowers and awakes.
Hey just, I hope It's just a phase your going through lol .. I can understand your fear of science but in the non cult world one doesn't need to believe everything one reads. To liken historians or any other scientists to the scribes that write watchtower and awake! is woeful in its ignorance. I don't even know where to start with that lol.There are threads here where people relate their JW experience. Do we have to believe these stories? No way! But personnaly I find that arround 100% of these history records ring true. And this is without anything remotely like the standard of proof and peer review required before one can successfuly publish history research (geez if you think JWD is a tough audience, try getting anything past the argumentative hawks of academia). They'd tear you to shreds over a misplaced commer (why does that ring a bell?).
Historians aren't dogmatic purveyors of bullshit any more than any other scientists. Some of my best friends are historians. They work hard and reveal much. A friend and neighbour of mine, Mark McKenna, has just published a book called 'looking for blackfellows point' in which he examines and documents the harsh treatment and massacre of Australias indigenous folk in the very early days of settlement here in the Bega Valley. His work in revealing things till now whispered about behind closed doors hasn't made him very popular with the locals but has won him many national awards from those who appreciate well researched work shining light into dark corners and asking questions about our past and present attitudes and behaviour.
We all have our own a basic frame work of facts to hang our ideas and we all vary in this. True histrory is fascinating and fun to explore. For me the earth is an old spherical rock spinning around a dying little star (I can only take the historians word on this - it's a pretty crazy idea but I'll buy it till the flat earth society gets their act together). For me t here is more fun and truth to be found in examination of the questions than will ever be found in the answers, a view shared by most historians amature and otherwise.
cheers unc who looks for questions.
ps: sorry for the ramble, hope it makes sense I'm not awake yet