Mordecai:
I do think it is very difficult to stand up for conscientious reasons in Israel.
You wrote:" The refuseniks are like the Jw's in some ways wouldn't you say"
If you mean by that, they are conscientous objectors , ( I believe) there is a distiction to be made.
JW's have been conscientious objectors. But was it because of conscience or WT directives? I cannot judge the motives of anyone,but if they had a choice some of them may have done otherwise.
A lot of the Israeli Refusniks were already soldiers willing to defend their state until they came to the realization that a "Black Cloud" was hanging over them. This is what makes their decision appear as a truly conscientious one.
They have come to believe (through first hand knowledge) that what they were doing in the IDF was totally incongruent with the principles of democracy and morality that their country is supposed to stand for.And they are experiencing hardships as a result. It was even suggested recently that they be put to death for their stance.
The Refuseniks remind me more of of the disident JW's who have come to realize that groupthink negates conscience. JW's who are willing to lose so much that has become precious to them (i.e. family,friends, lifestyle,etc,)in order to remain true to that voice within.
The children growing up in Israel have also been conditioned (from infancy)to think the way the organization wants them to think; and the responses they face for rejecting the "company line" are similar to what a JW experiences.
But there is something that makes their stand even more outstanding.
We are all familiar with the expression."A man can have no greater love than to lay down his life for his friends".
Well, the Refuseniks are putting everything on the line for people who have been their enemies.To me,that is certainly greater than the love mentioned above,and it puts CONSCIENCE on a higher plane than familial love.
I ,for one, have been inspired by this group.
Cookie