I appreciate Andi's stance on this as being one of balance.
I fail to understand what Trauma is bitching about and why he insists on bring up every personal clash he has with Bill to this site. It is just another tantrum from the drama hound imo. Bill is pig headed sometimes. That being said a more timid man wouldn't have had the fortitude to do what he has done to this point.
Yes Bill has alientated some. Show me any successful activist movement where everyone is happy with the process.
Looking at Charlie's post:
I did Bill a favor the other day, I get an e-mail back from him thanking me for it. if I wanted to work with silentlambs again, that I need to basically shutup, and not make any negative comments about them, and to stop posting private e-mails. I did something nice, a peace offering have you, and I get this diatribe in response, of complete falsehoods. I want to help people, but he is acting like an elder, and it's really starting to piss me off. What should I do?
You did a favour. He said thank you. He said he would welcome you back but with the stipulation that you quit yer bellyaching at sites and taking personal issues to public boards. I don't see why that should upset you. Is he asking something that is impossible from you?
So did you do that favor for Bill, for the Lambs? He did say thank you. Somehow I am left with the impression that no matter what Bill does you will find yet another reason to bitch about him here.
Do your own thing. You don't have to be associated with Silent Lambs to accomplish good things for survivors of abuse. If you do 'favors' for Silentlambs in the future, know the lambs are grateful and ignore the bowen factor.
Uzzah