Billygoat,
I hope you do not think I am evil and mean and I must be destroyed. LOL
I am really into American Idol. The only reason I want Josh off the show is because he cannot sing well. He needs a lot of work. I don't think he worked hard to get on the show. He was lucky. If he worked hard he would have a better voice. He sings technically wrong. He can be entertaining but at this point I would only be entertqained by him if I were hearing him sing at a karaoke bar. That is the God's honest truth. He needs a voacal coach I am sure that would really make a difference for him.
I heard that people on the show who are not so great (talent-wise) were only chosen in the beginning of the competitions by the judges to create drama during the finals. The show wouldn't be as exciting if all the contestants were great singers.
Josh's time is up!!! He's got to go. He seems like a nice person and I think it is great he is in the Marines. But he knows as well as everyone else he doesn't belong there anymore. The other performers are far more talented. It is not fair to them if he stays.
It is not personal. He just doesn't deserve to be on the show. I am basing this on their talent only.