I actually went around for a while thinking I would go to hell because I no longer believe in Jesus.
You were right. Without Christ Jesus, you will go to hell.
I don't know if before this experience of yours you were a JW. If you were, your destiny was the same. Nothing really changed in that respect.
I hope you come to realize that Jesus is the only way and that the Scriptures which speak of Him are true (NOT the New World Translation). They are the words of life, but Jesus Christ is that life. Faith in Him and following Him is what makes you a Christian. Again, a Christian is a follower of Jesus Christ, not being a "church goer" or a religious fenatic. Church won't save you, good work won't save you. Jesus Christ bore your sins on the cross that you might be saved if you would only believe on Him and follow.
Don't listen to the devil's lies.