Why can we LOSE our Religion, but not LOSE it's effects on us?

by gumby 33 Replies latest watchtower beliefs

  • moanzy
    moanzy

    Garybuss, sometimes I think we had the same parents. My parents didn't teach us coping skills, life skills essential to living happily and successfully or how to critically think. Nothing!!!! It was "the answer is in the book". If you answered correctly then apparently you were doing just fine.

    After leaving the witnesses I've not only had to tear apart the religious beliefs I was taught to believe as correct and from God, I had to start learning BASIC life skills I should have been learning from childhood to adulthood.

    I had to first identify what my problems were since in my mind it was just one big muddled mess of problems with no beginning and no end. Then after that I had to find ways of not only coping, but being able to put them into words I could understand and convey to others in order to get appropriate help.

    Now I'm at the place where I am able to experiment with skills I've learned in order to manage real life. At the same time I am trying to recognize when old habits of my JW thinking come up so that I can actively change some of my reactions. I don't know what age this puts me at, but at least I'm working at it.

    It is such a long process for those of us that grew up with no-minds for parents. I feel my parents stunted any normal growth in me because they found it easier to just keep me stupid.

    Thanks MOM!!!

    Moanzy

  • gumby
    gumby
    This may seem kind of mean, but, get over it. We are all the sum of our experiences. If I'd wallowed in resentment for losing my mom to mental illness when I was thirteen, losing my identity to an abusive husband at eighteen

    jgnat..you had some bad experiences at thirteen and eighteen. I wished I knew at 18 what I did now. I might have even went to college or invested money and planned for the future. Some of our witnesses experiences cannot be resolved or gotten over.

    If a man at 40 years of age that was born in the witness religion finally exits...it might take this man 5 to 10 years simply to gain back some sanity from an emotional blow such as finding out you were decieved for 40 years. You might have suffered depression and a host of other things and not really quite ready to pull yourself up by your boot strings right away.

    Now your 45, and your somewhat sane and you decide you want the education you missed...so you go to college for 3 or 4 years....now your 49. Gee, you got 6 more years and you can get the senior value meal at Dennys!

    Gumby

  • sass_my_frass
    sass_my_frass

    We all will to some extent. We probably don't realise how much of it we've already shaken off. But if it was ever a major part of our lives, it will always be with us to some small degree. We can learn to control it though, and see it working on us - that's something we can thank each other for.

  • gumby
    gumby


    Moanzy.....you've made many points I've been trying to say. The journey out can be a time consuming demon with little room for growth while dealing with exiting and the consequences it usually brings with it.

    I had to start learning BASIC life skills I should have been learning from childhood to adulthood.

    The life of every Jehovah's Witness is different. You...as was I, were raised in the cult. People who come into this faith with these skills you speak of are in a totally different world than is a dub who lived a nieve, sheltered world from birth. Sometimes I even wonder HOW a person can come into this cult at a later age AFTER they have lived a life of somewhat normallcy.....but they do.

    Dubs aren't the only ones who escape bondage of some type at an aged year in life...I realise.

    Gumby

  • uninformed
    uninformed

    Gumby,

    Thanks for starting a nice thread. I have enjoyed all the comments.

    I was especially impressed with eyeslice, and I sure do thank him for making the comment.

    I am 60 and have studied the WT pubs since I was 10 years old and baptized at 15. My whole history is tied in with the WT. I hate that, but there is nothing to do about it except commiserate with all of you. My respect and love to all of you.

    Brant

  • gumby
    gumby
    but there is nothing to do about it except commiserate with all of you.

    Aww brant....you still have a good 25 to 30 years left to go to accomplish things. You might have to be inventive in doing so, but it can be done. It's just sad many of us had to wait this long to move ahead.

    Gumby

  • bem
    bem

    (((((Undecided))))) I feel for you I did not spend as much of my life in the wts as others here have but I understand how confusing and depressing it is to get the old junk out of our systems and get on with life without letting the bitterness eat us up. You have relatives out also right? Take care of you.

    Dorothy

  • jgnat
    jgnat

    I hear you, gumby.

    Gee, you got 6 more years and you can get the senior value meal at Dennys!

    I did the math a few years ago and realized I would never get my investment back if I went back to school. So I decided to progress (slowly) at work and do the house-buying thing. I satisfy my craving for learning by reading. Just.

    I figure I'll get to school when I'm 65, and I'll do it for the sheer joy of learning.

  • Van Gogh
    Van Gogh

    Great and healing thread. I agree and empathize with everyone including uninformed: “there is nothing to do about it except commiserate with all of you. My respect and love to all of you.”
    Gumby,
    Yes, we are now convinced we made the right move and STILL suffer the effects it had on us.
    We cannot lose that religion as 'truth' because we keep looking to replace it with a truth or an answer somewhere “out there” “in the book” (moanzy). But as dreamer said: NO ONE has the right answer.
    Yes, many STILL have low self-esteem. Many have no confidence, feel unworthy, feel guilty.
    Jgnat said: we can’t loose our history; our brains are hard-wired; we need to rewrite the programming and choose to go contrary to our "instincts", despite the fact that our entire being tells us it is true. (dreamer). We have taken the “red pill” and rationally know the “truth” was not the truth. Like fullofdoubtnow, it would be nice to take the “blue pill” and blank it all out. But we can’t, because it is all we have and all we are: Our HISTORY, good and bad, MAKES US (jgnat).
    eyeslice put it concisely:
    “…a total loss of identity. I has been a witness all my life, had given up lots for my religion, education, work opportunities etc, and was therefore only defined by who I was as part of 'God's organization'. I suddenly lost all that through no fault of my own and although I thought I could just walk away, it has been a long hard and sometimes lonely walk.”
    This loss of identity can be compounded by parents who stunted any normal growth in the first place (moanzy and garybuss).
    After summarizing these comments, I think the problem is that we keep seeking answers OUTSIDE ourselves. We were conditioned to distrust ourselves (our wicked heart). We should of course look INSIDE. But then we have another problem: Which inner voice or gut feeling do we listen to if, at he same time, we have to go contrary to our instincts and what our entire being tells us is true?
    Yes, all these wasted years Jgnat… I agree with, and fully understand Gumby: “when you've become older, you don't feel you have ENOUGH time to learn… I'll be 70 when I'll learn things I shoulda known at 30!” but as you say, we’ve been through a unique experience. IMO age is crucial to some ones exit attitude. Raised as a JW and exiting over 40 it tends to become especially sobering. I found Ray Franz’s final words in CoC on his exit age and future prospects both poignant and consoling. Prolonging the WTS-induced self-doubt and cultivating a sceptical viewpoint can become a drag. Looking outside ourselves to others to see how we should be or could have been won’t make for much happiness either. In the end acceptance and forgiveness can make the seed bloom and make us bear fruit. We can choose to use those painful experiences make us MORE compassionate, MORE sensitive (Jgnat). Perhaps past experiences need to be conquered by those. Perhaps we’ll once find out that this is the reason we are/were here after all. Till we find out, faith is all we have.
    Peace to us all.
    VG

  • LittleToe
    LittleToe

    Van Gogh:
    Nice summary. You hit all the points I would have highlighted

    So, to the future: how do we find our identity, our self-confidence, our inner voice?

    Find that and you have the recipe for individual success that benefits not just you but those around you

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit