The Procedure of Disfellowshiping done by the Watchtower—Your Views

by The wanderer 21 Replies latest jw friends

  • The wanderer
    The wanderer
    The Procedure of Disfellowshiping done by the Watchtower—Your Views

    The inspiration of this post comes from two
    individuals who have recently gone thorough
    some challenges with the Watchtower Society.

    One was questioning the elders about the UN
    and never really received an answer regard-
    ing it. The other disassociated himself accord-
    ingly.

    Being in the Kingdom Hall when the announcement is made

    Anyone, who has spent time in the organization
    has probably at one time or another heard the
    announcement come from the podium. "So and
    so has been disfellowshiped from the Christian
    congregation."

    This announcement is usually accompanied by
    gasps, ooh's, ah's and then the gossiping
    speculation starts in.

    "What did he or she do?"

    "Commit fornication?"

    "Commit adultery?"

    " I knew so and so was up to no good!"

    " It figures because they were never that
    strong in the truth anyway."

    Airing out the dirty laundry

    All the nauseating dirty laundry seems to come
    out during this time. Usually the individual is
    "thrown to the lions" at that point and nothing
    is really mentioned in a good way about that
    person anymore.

    In a sense that individual becomes "obsolete."

    This leads to questions regarding Disfellowshiping

    For those of you who either were disfellowshiped
    or knew someone that was disfellowshiped can
    you describe the procedure as to what exactly
    happens?

    We are not interested in what caused the
    individual to become disfellowshiped only
    the procedure involved and the feelings
    and aftermath.

    As the author of this article it gives me
    no pleasure to rip open old wounds and
    I do sincerely apologize for doing so.

    However, for those who lack under-
    standing can you please share these
    experiences with others on the board.

    Respectfully,

    The Wanderer

  • cyberdyne systems 101
    cyberdyne systems 101

    I didnt attend the JC that disfellowshipped me, but going on a previous one, it was a case of bullying you into submission and guilt by probing your every thought and action, it was done in secret with you facing up to four Elders all firing questions at you.

    CS 101

  • jgnat
    jgnat

    For accuracy sake, the announcement is, "So-and-so is no longer one of Jehovah's Witnesses." The society no longer distinguishes the disfellowshipped from the disassociated, at least in the public announcement.

    http://www.answers.com/topic/jehovah-s-witnesses-and-congregational-discipline

    Elders announcing a "wrongdoer" on his doorstep that he has been disfellowshipped. Feel the love. Note the procedure and the consequences the elder was driven to explain to the unwilling householder.

    http://www.watchtowerinformationservice.org/?p=337&cp=5

  • AK - Jeff
    AK - Jeff

    A Link that discusses the matter in detail- especially helpful to lurkers, since as Jw's you wish to see the scriptural reasoning on this most important part of your religious culture -

    http://jwfacts.com/index_files/disfellowship.htm

    I always thought it was wrong-headed in it's application. It is never administered as 'a loving arrangement' as they say. It is always punitive in nature, and intensely damaging to one's self esteem, reputation in his community, and straining to relationships within even his intimate family.

    How can anyone - even witnesses - believe that God wants them to one day, pray with, encourage, and love without end, his child, parent or close friend, and then the next day, following a 10 second sound byte from the platform, stop doing those things. It is like turning off a switch on one's emotions. It is unconsciencable punishment. Add to that it's non scriptural support.

    Jeff

  • hambeak
    hambeak

    I have not been df'd to my knowledge but I have been to a committee meeting and what I experienced was a power trip and the ones there have preconceived ideas and their minds are made up. Love there? bull dodo they are on a power trip

  • The wanderer
    The wanderer

    Dear Jgnat:

    Thank you for the correction.

    Respectfully,

    The Wanderer

  • ButtLight
    ButtLight

    The first time I was dfed, there were alot of "oohs" and "ahhhs" and lots and lots of looks! I wanted to crawl under my chair. Surely didnt go to my second dfing for more of that!

  • minimus
    minimus

    As an elder serving on JCs for many years, I'll give you my opinion. This procedure is UNSCRIPTURAL. It is totally an organizational tool to keep persons in line. You take away all of their dignity and abuse them mentally, spiritually and psychologically. The aim is to break them down and make them realize that everything they do with family and friends, if they are Witnesses, is never going to happen again unless they adhere to every minute ruling that the JC metes out. It is CRUEL and UNUSUAL punishment---not Christlike at all!!!!

  • OUTLAW
    OUTLAW

    Never been disfellowshiped..Been to a few JC`s though..LOL!!..It was a Kangaroo Court..They were usually in shock and or laughing..I was a brilliant practical joker..LOL!!...OUTLAW

  • purplesofa
    purplesofa

    When I was DF, the sin was reported ( I had a hickey on my neck)

    I went before a JC, they asked tons of questions, and said we would meet again at specified time.

    We talked again, and I guess they thought I was unrepentant as I was DF. The reason fornication.

    I was alone. 27 yrs old w/ 5 kids(oldest was 8) .......newly baptised and newly divorced. My stepfather had recently commited suicide. I went from a six digit income to welfare. I was so totally lonely feeling. It was overwhelming and the stress........to this day I don't know who that person was that survived those years. I had distanced myself from all my "worldy" friends working my way to baptism. So the decision meant I had NOBODY.

    I can't remember all the things discussed at the second JC meeting. When they tell you to wait outside while they make a decision, I think I just about had a meltdown. My face got so hot and I cried hysterically, pacing and walking round the hall in the dark. I could hardly breath. Snot bubbles coming out my nose. I do not even remember the words they used when they called me back in with the DF decision. I think they told me I could continue to pray. They never told me how to work my way back. I was so new in the truth, I did not know any of the politics. When it was announced the congo was in shock and most cried. I was their little pet for so long. And they knew what kind of troubles I was having personally. I was the bible study that stood up to my husband and refused a Chritmas tree in the house with five kids....and got thrown out of my house making that stand. The elders went to my ex to reason with him to let me back home.

    I got a death sentence. I distanced myself from all my "worldy" friends. The decision meant I had NOBODY.

    There was one sister from the hall. She worked at the electric company. When I would go to pay my bill she would smile at me. One time she showed me pics of her kids. It felt good to be acknowledged by her. I felt like the lowest scum from the earth. Not even worthy to be breathing air. I was totally ashamed. I was going to die at Armegeddon and so were my kids.

    Niine years passed and I was reinstated. Shortly after that I was before a JC again for the same offense. While the first offense was a reaction to stress and drinking and just something crazy, the second was not..........it was for the pure fun and pleasure raging hormones to have sex. I was coached heavliy on how to conduct myself and what to say and ask before a committee. Stay lowly, admit you wanted it and that you are very very sorry. I told them it was more than once.......I said I thought after the first time why not do it more? I said I have been DF for this before and just got reinstated and here I am again before you with the same offense.

    The sin was with a brother, the first offense was with someone worldly. I told them the brother said to me as long as we were going to marry it was ok for us to have sex. He said there were places in the bible that said that. I told the elders I looked and looked but found no places in the bible where sex before marriage was ok.

    The outcome went totally different. When they told me to wait outside while they make a decision .........I said and asked.........If you decide to DF me, please give me something to work on. The last time I was just thrown out in the cold, not knowing at all what to do or how to really change the behaviour.

    I went back in and the elders told me that since my first committee meeting the elders had learned alot. Now my circumstances would be taken into consideration. They were very nice and compassionate. Honestly they were. I was put on private reproof.

    These were not the same elders from first JC committee. As a matter of fact it was a totally different state.

    I have been divorced for 20 years, I guess I like sex but don't want to be married. I don't know.

    purps

    edited to add: Was this too much information?

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit