Corey....
I was worried about you!
As for this "faith"....I know it might sound simplistic, but I saw a movie and heard this quote from the Gospel of Thomas, and all of a sudden it hit me like a brick.
"The Kingdom of God is inside you and all about you, not in mansions of wood and stone. Split a piece of wood and I am there; lift a stone and you will find me."
God is IN us. Not in some brick building...not in a KH with no windows....not in a huge cathedral....not in an organization worth billions of $$$$. That may be why you aren't comfortable in another church. And why you have left the organization. That one thing opened my eyes.
Now I see God (or Goddess) in everything, and everywhere. I stop and look at a beautiful yellow bird singing....and that awesome feeling I get when I hear the sound is God. I smell the scent of honeysuckle...I close my eyes, and there is that same feeling. When I look at my little granddaughters smile and see her laughing eyes, that warmth inside is "the kingdom of God inside me." It's all around you...just "notice" it.
And when bad...terrible things happen, and you feel sad, lonely, and lost...that is once again God (or a higher power) inside you telling you things are not right.
Something else I always thought was wrong while a witness...going to the KH, going in field service...doing all these things man tells you to do...to get into the New Earth. All for some kind of reward. Now, I consider myself a cross between a religious and a secular "humanist." I try to behave decently without any expectation of a "new earth," everlasting life, or hell/punishment after I'm dead.
According to humanism, it is up to humans to find the truth within ourselves. The focus is on doing good and living well in the here and now, and leaving the world better for those who come after, not on suffering through life to be rewarded afterward.
You will find your "faith," Corey. I know it. If you are searching, it will come to you.