QFR Regarding How The "Slave" Is "Discreet"

by minimus 33 Replies latest jw friends

  • Leolaia
    Leolaia
    BTW, what is your background in all this, are you a closet theologian?

    LOL...That's a pretty good guess, although less a theologian than a "closet" literary critic I guess. I did some classics in college and I'm a linguist professionally (studying syntax, pragmatics, social setting, etc.), but NOT professionally in biblical studies though I would love to get my feet wet there if I ever had the chance. I am most interested in issues pertaining to composition of texts, their transmission, and their subsequent interpretation.

  • Leolaia
    Leolaia

    Let me connect all this to the main point of the thread. The parabolic slave is described as phronimos which means "prudent" or "acting with discretion". Joseph was described in the same way. In that case, Joseph understood what was going to happen and he prepared accordingly. He recognized that the "appointed time" of plenty was a time to store food in anticipation of the foretold famine. Then the "appointed time" of seven years of famine arrived and he again acted acccordingly by opening up the storehouse and judiciously rationing out grain to the people, not only preventing disaster but also bringing great wealth to his king. A different but similar scenario plays out in the parable. The prudent servant understands what will happen (i.e. the parousia) and prepares accordingly. He recognizes that the present is an "appointed time" (kairos) in which the master is away and pastoral care of fellow believers is necessary. He properly anticipates the "appointed time" in which the master returns and acts accordingly. The imprudent servant, on the other hand, neglects his pastoral duty on the mistaken impression that the master is coming at some other "appointed time". He fails to adequately prepare for the master's arrival and not only is he incompetent but he mistreats his fellow believers as well.

    The Society has undeniably acted "imprudently" with respect to the expected "appointed time" of the parousia....claiming that it has already arrived and that the visible return of the master in judgment is (always) at hand, thereby advising fellow believers to put off marriage, education, work, even living life on the basis of an eschatological expectation that has never materialized at the "appointed time" claimed by the Society. In a sense, they do not claim that the expected time is "delayed" as they continually say it is at hand (and thus are closer to the false prophets condemned in the same chapter of Matthew who say that the "time is at hand"), but through their actions they declare it to be perpetually delayed because things have never happened as soon as they expect. The example of Joseph supplies an interesting contrast to the Society. He is presented as both recognizing the future accurately and preparing adequately for it. The Society claims to know what will happen but they continually fail to prepare for what actually materializes.

  • Terry
    Terry

    If you could get the sense of the parallel between the FDS parable and the Joseph story in the LXX down to one flowing 75 word paragraph you might have a real nuclear arsenal.

    You want to take a crack at that Leolaia?

    The reason for this is obvious; the rank and file JW who might benefit most from such a demonstration of misapplication of FDS to the Watchtower bully boys, will not crunch the weighty matters. It has to flow trippingly on the tongue and have some real bite.

    I think you can do it. God knows I don't want to try right now.

  • minimus
    minimus

    Terry, you're funny. Don't ask for the impossible.

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit