One reason why I dislike posting is because of the possibility to be totally misinterpreted by other posters. I can understand how my comments might have seemed that I was standing in judgment of Oompa or anyone else in his position! I definitely did not mean to give that impression, but you can't tell that just by text alone.
I was trying to explain (and obviously not very well!) how difficult it was for me, because of my upbringing, to understand how elders justify drinking at all, let alone heavy drinking. The elders who have studied with me have all joked about their heavy consumption of hard liquor. (It totally shocked me at the time). I didn't realize when I started studying with them that they were really miserable on the inside from being beaten by the org with constant demands for more work, and changing doctrines that left their heads spinning.
I also think that for elders to try and offer counsel on this if they are heavy drinkers themselves and to disfellowship people as a result of the same thing that they struggle with is very hypocritical and unloving. I definitely do not see that as following the example of Christ, the good Shepherd.
I am really concerned about Oompa and I hope that he can one day be finally free from the demons that are haunting him. I have already contacted him to ask for forgiveness if I caused additional hurt by my post. I am also very sorry if it caused anyone reading it to feel discouraged or that it was unloving or condescending. If you actually knew me as a person, you would know that is definitely not the type of person I am.
Sunspot asked:
Is your status as a "non-drinking Christian" a personal choice to NOT ever imbibe, or do you feel that it rests on a biblical command to not do so?
It is mostly the first, although I have been taught that alcohol was used for disinfection purposes in water and was very watered down. I have family and friends that drink wine, believing that the Bible allows for this, and I respect their postition on this matter as one of conscience. I hope you understand that I don't want to hijack this thread and get into a debate over this issue.
Locutus said:
I respect where you are coming from but you are coming across to me as very judgemental. I have walked in Oompa's shoes, have you? your comment comes across as condescending. The LAST thing Oompa needs is a bunch of bible verses up in his face. He needs understanding, empathy and support.
I totally agree! and that was totally not my intention!
Eclipse said:
what is it exactly that you don't chew? - food? meat? body parts?
That's funny! The little rhyme is from the earlier part of the 1900s, I think, and referred back to chewing tobacco. I always thought it was a very corny way to express convictions. I never said it myself, and in fact I did "go with boys" that drank socially.
Satanus said:
Your quotes show that there is a time to drink. So, how can you be judgemental if a person in much pain follows what your quotes say? It's a form of medication, which you amply show that the bible advocates.
That was actually the point I meant to make! Thanks for stating what I should have said in the first post. Those Bible verses absoultely make sense to me NOW that I understand the pain that the Witness religion causes to its followers. It is a terrible, terrible thing!
Are you suggesting that someone in the position of oompa should not feel pain?
Absolutely not! He has my deepest compassion, and I wish that I lived closer to him so that I could be of some practical support.
Sorry for the confusion, guys, I will try and be more coherent next time.