Right then part three
<<<<<<<<<<
Do you have credible source that says otherwise? To say that a Chilean volcano has emitted more CO2 than all human activity since WWII, the USGS have to be off by several orders of magnitude.
Comment by Richard Cochrane on 9 November 2009:
gbeauregard The source is cited and its cover pictured in the in the original post. Google it.
By the way the 2002 USGS report has been widely questioned and I believe it has been amended. In fairness its calculation were 2002 and not 2009 so there is a 7 year gap.
Certainly this is an ongoing debate mostly between government agencies and private scientists. One with its hand in the taxpayer pocket and one without.
Comment by gbeauregard on 12 November 2009:
>> The source is cited and its cover pictured in the in the original post. Google it.
The source whose cover picture you included is National Geographic’s “Six Degrees Could Change the World”, which is based on Mark Lynas’ book “Six Degrees: Our Future on a Hotter Planet”. I’ve watched the video, and read the book. (The book’s quite good - very well researched and referenced. The video is disappointingly shallow).
Neither the book nor the video mentioned a volcano in southern Chile that’s spitting out in two weeks “more CO2 (Carbon Dioxide) than the sum total of all human activity has in more than two decades”. This is hardly surprising, since that would undermine their thrust that greenhouse gas emissions from human activity are causing climate change.
So again: can you point to a credible source that that does back up your claim?
Incidentally, the country is “Chile”, not “Chili”. Google it
Comment by Richard Cochrane on 13 November 2009:
I should have specified greenhouse gases and not fallen victom to the Gore shorthand of Carbon Dioxide. Conclusions from researchers funded by the National Science Foundation, French Polar Institute (IPEV) and the Institut National des Sciences del’Univers (INSU) and a plethora of others
Comment by gbeauregard on 13 November 2009:
So I take it you’re now claiming that researchers funded by the NSF, IPEV, and INSU have concluded that that a Chilean volcano has emitted more greenhouse gases than all human activity in the last two decades? Credible references welcome. Good luck finding any
From what I’ve read, volcanic eruptions do have a significant short-term impact on climate, in that the aerosol