He infuriates you when you talk to him because he is so morally superior sounding. He never yields an inch and never remembers the previous conversation you had. He has a Recycle Bin in his head and he simply "deletes" after talking to you.
The person you refer to resembles those that I have met in the organization that believe that they have achieved some spiritual insight that makes them unique within the spiritual fold. The heirarchy is in place and people with higher intelligence have to yeild to inferior thinkers. You are punished for even trying to suggest that you might be smarter.
The organization does not cater to intelligent people nor do they try to dominate them. It's an issue of loyalty or obedience. The underlying issue is that they call the shots whether you like it or not. Anyone wanting to use their God-given minds will be ostracized because God gave them the authority and not you. Is it any wonder that so many within the fold would find themselves wanting and seek those that would give them some reprieve from a self-appointed, incompetent, leadership. They know how to manufacture scriptures that support their cause while ignoring those that expose them as a false religion.
Your friend has been living a lie just as I was for so many years.
The fact that he chooses to lie to inferiors doesn't change anything. That's what a hostage does to survive. I suspect that his conversations with you gave him some liberation for a moment, intellectually and spiritually.
You have a history with him and know him: I don't. The only thing that I can share with you is that I know witnesses that left the organization for legitimate reasons and still came back. They were never treated like lost sheep; it was a matter of coming to your senses.
The organization does no wrong and you are not allowed to contemplate that. According to the scriptures, Jesus set a higher standard. The organization doesn't have to and yet they claim to respect his leadership.
The end of it all is I know people like him (many are elders). The only thing that I can say is that there is truth and honesty and there are witnesses (elders) that choose to live a lie. Lying becomes a way of life for those that profess to have the 'truth'.