Getting into Arguments with JW's...

by ForbiddenFruit 159 Replies latest watchtower beliefs

  • not a captive
    not a captive

    MadJ, Sorry I seemed to drop out. Am considering our discussion,how to get it off high center. Also my job taking care of a little boy with CP has been particularly wearing this past week. And I'm going to have to move at the end of the month after my youngest gradutes HS in a couple of weeks. However, this dialog is certainly an exchange that stays present in my thoughts and I hope to give you your due in the next day or so.

    I wouldn't just drop out so rudely as that. Maeve

  • not a captive
    not a captive

    Shamus, Is your solicitation for a kiss a general invitation or ?

    I would hate for either of us to feel left out. So here.

    Glad to meet you. Maeve

  • theMadJW
    theMadJW

    No prob, NAC: I'm buried in work, and helping friends unemployed...

  • not a captive
    not a captive

    In looking at the difference between "sacrifice" and "burnt offering" and why Jesus' Father would not have commanded Abraham to do both:

    Been thinking... the difficulty of communicating a thought from one human to another (marriage is like that too) is so much evident in our discussion. Don't you see how God would have over-run Abraham's thought processes to instil His meaning--that would have been violating the essences of what listening is. God had to present a dilemna to Abraham that Jesus spoke of later:" 'I am the God of Abraham, the God of Isaac, And the God of Jacob.' He is not the God of the dead but of the living." Matt. 22:32

    Just a thought . Not done thinking. Gotta go to work now.

    Maeve

  • Black Sheep
    Black Sheep

    I got over those sorts of dilemmas when I realised that other cultures had similar, but just as unrealsistic, scenarios in them.

    e.g. Would I be having the same problems as I have with my parent's version of creation if they had been Australian Aborigines instead of followers of a Middle Eastern cult?

    Before you start arguing the toss over the meanings of the religious book that was chosen for you by your parents you have to ask youself if it really is relevant. I forgot to do that. Dad forgot to do that. Mum forgot to do that.

    Why should the folklore of Middle Eastern goat herders have precedence over the folklore of Australian Aborigines? The Abos were in Australia 30,000 years before the goat herder's Adam was even created.... and goat herder's creator forgot that Adam needed a woman to procreate....Duh...."Whoops. Sorry Adam, I made you a willy and forgot you might want to use it for more than pissin outa."............. and I am supposed to believe that????

    Cheers

    Chris

  • Terry
    Terry
    Jehovah planned to send His son to die, and wanted all to understand the sacrifice HE was going to make.

    Really? Who understood this? When did they understand it?

    How was it a "sacrifice" to send His son? Jehovah got him back didn't he?

    Nobody understood anything at any time as far as I can see.

    Isaac didn't really die. Jesus did.

    Why wouldn't it simply be effective for Jesus to be pulled down from crucifixion BEFORE he died and count it as a win?

  • shamus100
    shamus100

    Terry,

    Don't you understand, silly? In the fairy-tale book dubbers paint he gave up his humanly body forever.... like anyone would want to be a 'lower' lifeform anyways.

    So here's a good similarity for all of us to understand, friendo.

    Let's say you like squirrels. You study them, then they're bad, you drown all of them but seven, then let them loose to repopulate the earth after watching thousands of them drown, then you send your only begotten son down to save them and have the other squirrels crucify your son till your squirrel son expires, then you resurrect your squirrel son, knowing full well that your son will never be a squirrel again.

    How sad... how sad...

    What did we learn today? Your son will never be a squirrel again.

    Kiss me!

  • Terry
    Terry

    Oh.

  • shamus100
    shamus100

    That's not much of a kiss!

  • theMadJW
    theMadJW

    This isn't much of a Topic....

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit