The quiet voice in my head that would say, even as a teenager, while reading WT articles, it sounds like they're guessing here. And the Proclaimers book, the Rutherford transition--I remember saying to myself, gee, this sounds more like a power struggle amongst businessmen than it does a story about the origins of THE Christian congregation.
There were also those talks with the anecdote about the guy who decides to leave the JWs, goes to a bar and gets beaten to death the same night. I always figured, well, obviously not everyone who is not a JW has been beaten to death in a bar, so...isn't there an orderly, rational way to leave this religion if one wanted to? Shouldn't we be happy to stay, not merely afraid to leave?
-sd-7