Are they really that bad??? (page 29)

debator

ad hominem attacks as rebuttal! none worth replying too.

lion cask if you find ad hominem attacks as better arguments and completely ignoring the points actually raised then who really is not facing reality?

Jookbeard "appeal to emotion" is equally a weak argument. Your hearsay account gives only the briefest info with only your emotive spin on it.

Lion Cask

lion cask if you find ad hominem attacks as better arguments and completely ignoring the points actually raised then who really is not facing reality?

Here I thought I was paying you a compliment, debator. Of course, if you are really just playing a role then your response to my compliment is entirely predictable. Well done. However, what I have noticed from reading older threads to which you have contributed is a subtle penchant you have for not answering certain questions. For example, were you really known as Reniaa in an earlier incarnation? Seems like a simple yes/no question.

Thank you for the open invitation, isaacaustin. I just may take you up on it sometime.

LC

debator

Hi Lion Cask

If they want to think I am earlier posters that is their choice.

If they call me debator I will answer. If they call me by other names I am unlikely to spot that it is me they are wanting a reply from.

Now have you got any points on the actual topics under discussion?

OUTLAW

Hi Lion Cask

If they want to think I am earlier posters that is their choice.....debator/Reniaa

Typical Reniaa non-Answer..

If they call me debator I will answer. If they call me by other names I am unlikely to spot that it is me they are wanting a reply from.....debator/Reniaa

Reniaa can`t see the name Reniaa..

Now have you got any points on the actual topics under discussion?.....debator/Reniaa

Translation.."Do you have any questions I`m willing to answer?"..

.................... ...OUTLAW

bohm

Debator:

"I answered your questions but I just clarified them as well, which you didn't like since you are clearly either saying God's people are meant to be perfect which we are not. Or that we shouldn't use supportive literature which in it's uninspired state can have errors which happen"

There are three things.

First i have NEVER said i expect Jehovahs witnesses to be perfect, or that imperfection constitute a particular great problem for me. your simply setting up a strawman.
Secondly, I have NEVER said jehovahs witness should not use supportive litterature. Again you are simply making a strawman.
Thirdly, no, you have not answered my question. I asked you if something that was printed in a particular watchtower was still true or not. You have not answered that. So was it true or was it false??? Why dont you want to answer such a simple question?

Quit making up lies about what i have written, or pretend you can read my mind!

And by just sticking to prophecy and culture issues. I find this very slippery of you Bohm but Your not the only one on these that does this.

But Debator man! The cultural issue i take up, blood, is nothing more than asking you if something the watchtower wrote is still true or not! It have got to be the most neutral of questions; I didnt bring it up, the watchtower did, and its important enough for them to let some of their members children die (or "put God first", if you recall that Awake) so how cant i simply ask if something they once taught on that subject is true or not?

No, YOU keep pretending you can read my mind, thereby attributing all kinds of bad intentions and dishonesty to me that only exist in your mind (its wrong! i should know, its my mind!), and thereby you detract from the issue.

I simply dont get why you cant answer the question.

bohm

Lion Cask wrote: For example, were you really known as Reniaa in an earlier incarnation? Seems like a simple yes/no question.

Debator answered: If they want to think I am earlier posters that is their choice.

Debator: Its a yes/no question and you dodge it. bravo.... I bet i could ask anyone on this thread if they was once known as some other poster, and they would answer me without batting an eye. You, on the other hand, somehow cant. Does it not concern you the least bit that the way you keep dodging questions and give non-answers is exactly how politicians argue?

How can one expect to be credible when he/she is ingenuous? Is this typical of devoted Jehovah's Witnesses?....Lion Cask

Reniaa is not an Active,follow the WBT$ Rules,JW..

Reniaa poses as a JW..

We have JWN Members here,who have never been JW`s..

And..

Have a Better Grasp of what it is to be a JW,than debator/Reniaa..

.................... ...OUTLAW

Lion Cask

Thank you, OUTLAW. I expect you may be right. What ever happened to the Reniaa incarnation? Was it terminated for being insufferable?

Are they really that bad???

Share this