Starting over.....I don't know how old you are or where you are at with your life. That being said, I once thought divorce might be inevitable even though I love my wife, simply because of the fights over religion. How it worked out is quite different. I began to not argue with her. Just to ask questions, and sincerely tell her how and why I felt things. Basically, I let her see the anguish it gave me to question my faith (and I put some extras on it).
She eventually began to explain why she REALLY felt so defensive. At this point because of my fade, she began to be treated differently. She now has her own fade in tow, and the challenges that go with it. All of this started because we both REALLY loved each other more than anything else. On top of that, she TRUSTED me and knew that i would not leave her if she left being a JW, so why would she?
Alot of it comes to that. If you really love her, then give her some space, go about it more methodically, and ask her to really sit down and discuss difficult things with you so that you can know where each other stands, and talk as adults reasonably.
Then give it a go. If you love her its worth a shot. If she can't break from it mentally, then its best you move on now....rip the band-aid off.