I can say from first hand experience, the three chord analogy is total bullshit! My ex and I were very spiritual and worked hard at our duties and responsabilities in the KH, so much that we began to ignore the fact that we began to grow apart. We started fighting more and more. Suddenly, i realised we werent friends anymore and didnt really love each other. We wanted very different things and once I woke up to TTATT it was all over.
My new marriage doesnt have the shackles of the duties that being a JW carries. We both have full time jobs and we both work extra hours here and there. I am now in the online Nursing program which gets pretty stressfull sometimes. But all the spare time we have we spend together. There is a big difference between the responsibilities of school and those of being Jdub.
School is working towards a tangible future. Its a absolute goal. Its a goal that my family will benefit from for the rest of my life. Once finished, no one can take that accomplishment away. Yes Im sacrificing alot of time and money but the benefits will last for the rest of our lives.
The benefits of Jdub duties and privilidges are not tangible. They are all for some future blessing of living forever on paradise Earth. You dont get money for it to help with family and expenses nor do you get real support when faced with hard times. They take up all your free time, you sacrifice so much with real little in return and, in the end, they can take all your hard work and accomplishments away in one swift move.
I also think that constantly having watchtowers, elders and others in your face telling you how you should be a "good" husband or "good" wife is not helpful in any way. The fact is, there is no formula. No one gets married to get divorced,it just happens. Sometimes two people should not be together and it really doesnt matter what you do to change that. Nothing, not friends, family, counselors, therapists or religion can change it. Even when you do find someone you love and they love you, I think it still comes down to tolerance and patience. Can you patiently tolerate each other and, at the same time, grow as an individual and couple? Nothing can garauntee this or predict how long it lasts you just take it day by day.
I dont know. Just my two cents.