I am very sorry you feel this issue is turning people away from the Gospel. I think because of the heavy bill collection style used on most church platforms, Leaders and TV Evanglist have made it an issue long before I have.
I feel tithing subject hits a raw nerve with a lot of folks churched or not.
Tonight, I went to the first class in my Chaplincy training. One of the questions asked to the Class was name one reason why a person does not go to church. The loudest and most emphazied one is how Churches and Christian based ministries are hitting them up for money all the time.
I don't think airing my views on tithing on this board has damaged "enemies of the Gospel "as you put it anymore or less towards the Gospel. I feel it shows how heavy handed preaching on the subject has made more enemies of the Gospel than my little thread. Pastors, TV Evangleist and Denominations are turning the stomach than I who brings up a very real subject which is well known outside of the church. In 1998 the Boston Globe ran an article "Pentacostals give God thier due." All the article talked about is how they give God 10% of their income. It is so part of pop culture to see TV preachers begging for money. Sadly most live in the lap of luxury while many Christians struggle to get out of debt or make ends meet.
Did Jesus live such a lavish lifestyle? Where does it say in the Bible Christian Church must give 10% did not Apostle Paul work instead of asking the Chruch to pay him?
I beleive it is so indoctrinated, Many Christians will belive it or fear the fact if they don't give bad things will happen. I mean you are stealing from God if 10% is not given, right? Guilt trip is repeated and embedded from week to week. I won't even talk about Christian media who drills it on every program. Not includes asking for donations to support their ministries.
Southren Bapisit are very big into the concept of 10% tithe. Have you ever tired to reason with a Southren Bapist on this subject, let alone the Pastor? They know how my husband and I feel about it and use sciptures to back up our view. It puts us on the butt end, because the life blood today of any church is how much money can be collected.
If a person choose to Tithe and belive it is a requirement I will respect thier belif. I don't have to agree with it, but if a person make a choice to give 10% it is between them and God.
I believe a Christian should have desinated in thier budget a regular donation. It is given freely and not under compulsion. A church who is not heavy handed about donations is more in the way of the 1 century model.
I felt it a subject which should be brought up here. Can you see the fruits of the crop of Churches and TV evanglist are producing in those who listen and worship at the various churchs?
I like to see more Christians donate something more valuble which is their time. Where has discipleship gone? Why is the Christian Churchso Scripturally Iliterate when it come to why they belive what they do. I know more can quote off the top of their heads on Tithing though. Why do you think this is so?