How Much is Personal Responsibility vs WTS' Fault?

by Prisca 39 Replies latest jw friends

  • Prisca
    Prisca

    The current discussion of an ex-GB member has prompted me to ponder this question:

    Just how much of our personal circumstances can/do we take responsibility for, and how much do we blame the WTS?

    You may have grown up as a JW, coerced into leaving early to pioneer, not go to university, have no kids, even stay single for the pursuit of singleness in the Kingdom work to pioneer or go to Bethel. If you had kids, we may have raised them to be good JWs, so much so that they know shun you. You may have taken up basic employment, in order to pioneer, or trying to heed the WTS' "suggestions" that we do not live a life of materialism. Because you did this you now have no real employment opportunities, or have an earning capacity well below that of your peers.

    Whilst many of us made decisions that were influenced by the WTS, how much of it do you think we should accept personal responsibility for? No one forced us to take up a basic job, no one physically prevented us from going to university, nor did they force us to take birth control in order to be freer to "pursue Kingdom interests".

    Some of the decision making was due to our own thinking/preferences, influenced by factors that were not in the WTS' control.

    Now that we are no longer JWs, how much can we continue to blame the WTS for how we live our life NOW? Since we are no longer JWs, we now have the freedom to pursue life choices that were never available before. If we wanted to go to university, what is preventing us from going now? If we wanted to change careers, what is stopping us now?

    Are all the obsticles we have in our life entirely the WTS' fault? How much of it can we change, and are we willing to change our lives in order to achieve our goals? Or are we too happy to sit down and complain, blaming everyone and everything but not ourselves? Or are we willing to admit that we made mistakes, and that it is now up to us to make our lives the kind of lives we want to live?

  • minimus
    minimus

    Some people will blame their parents, spouse, work or religion for anything they do not want to accept responsibility for. But you have to admit, there's a lot of baggage brought on to people who were/are JW's. But when I see people blame everything that goes wrong in their life because of being a Witness, a reality check is in order. Some people have to learn to carry on and move ahead or before you know it, their lives will be over.

  • Amazing
    Amazing

    Good questions Prisca: I think it all depends on how much harm was done for how long. It also depends on the personalities as to the extent of the harm.

    For example, it has not hurt me personally that I did not celebrate all the holidays, birthdays, etc ... so, I can take charge and see to it my grandchildren enjoy them. On the other hand, the missed business advancement, getting stronger financially, or developing my professional career were inhibited, and as a result I may be harmed forever ... I might have been President of the USA by now ... still ...

    I also believe that we only stop being victims when we decide to not let the Watchtower rule our futures emotionally and literally. There has to come a point when we can let it go, forgive the past and be at peace. We need to see life as a full and complete picture and not just a function of what it was in the JW context ... our lives are so much more than our JW experience or what the Watchtower did or failed to do ...

    Nonetheless, I also believe in some accountability ... and ... since the WTS refuses to be accountable, they must be forced into it, spanked, disciplined in the courts. They need to have their assets seized to get their materialistic attention ... and the attention of the rank and file JW ... and then they might pay some restitution to the most harmed victims ... and hopefully learn and grow as a religion.

    Finally, I believe that the ultimate power is in each of our own hands to take charge of our lives, and move forward. In retrospect, while I find more and more of the WTS to be a silly little religion that really duped people, and caused harm, I also find that much of their system is nothing more than a set of beliefs that we can easily disgarded as kid stuff ... they can keep their immature comic book religion and put it where the sun don't shine.

    We can really in our hearts, once freed from it, that the Watchtower has fallen.

  • teenyuck
    teenyuck

    I believe you stop being a victim when you want...

    Now that we are no longer JWs, how much can we continue to blame the WTS for how we live our life NOW? Since we are no longer JWs, we now have the freedom to pursue life choices that were never available before. If we wanted to go to university, what is preventing us from going now? If we wanted to change careers, what is stopping us now?

    Are all the obsticles we have in our life entirely the WTS' fault? How much of it can we change, and are we willing to change our lives in order to achieve our goals? Or are we too happy to sit down and complain, blaming everyone and everything but not ourselves? Or are we willing to admit that we made mistakes, and that it is now up to us to make our lives the kind of lives we want to live?

    However, I do not believe in *reparations* for *lost anything*.

    Nonetheless, I also believe in some accountability ... and ... since the WTS refuses to be accountable, they must be forced into it, spanked, disciplined in the courts. They need to have their assets seized to get their materialistic attention ... and the attention of the rank and file JW ... and then they might pay some restitution to the most harmed victims ... and hopefully learn and grow as a religion.

    Blaming the WTBTS for not having kids, not getting an education, etc. is ridiculous. Every court in America, even California, would throw it out.

    Donkey put up a thread about stealing $1 million from the WTS....would you do it if you were not caught? I said NO. Below are my responses:

    http://www.jehovahs-witness.com/6/56058/1.ashx

    So for all who answer NO to scenario 2: If someone wrongfully imprisoned you or if someone deprived you of an education that would have enabled you over 25 to 30 years to have earned in excess of a million dollars and you had the opportunity to take a million dollars from them without you knowing it would you do it? You say No - then you deserve to be suckered. You say yes - I say what's the difference between that and scenario number 2?

    MY RESPONSE:

    Wrongfully imprisoned? How? Please explain.

    Deprived of an education? That one is parental and a personal responsibility. I happened to have a *progressive* mother who didn't think I could/would make it as a pioneer (read spiritually weak) therefore no good JW boy would want me, therefore I needed an education to get out of her house ASAP. Because I was, in her words, "A milstone around my neck."

    Fine. You know what I did? I got student loans. I got grants. We were poor. I worked, I went to class and I lived at home. 10 years later, in 1994, I payed off my last student loan.

    Blaming the WTBTS for your lack of education is another form of "I am the victim" mentality and really pisses me off.

    Every single person on this board is smart enough to go to college. If you can use a computer, you can enroll in on-line class.

    If you didn't get to go when you were 18 the only thing you missed was beer poisoning and panty raids. BFD.

    WHHHAAA!!!

    The Watchtower convinced my parents that I didn't need an education. So what is stopping you now?

    You have a computer. You have *some* money. You have time. (time being: time to sit here. get your ass in a class and learn something!!) If it takes you 10 years to do it; DO IT. It is worth it. The personal satisfaction is tremendous.

    The WTBTS does not *owe* anyone here anything. Yes they fucked up many, many lives. However, you are out. You are responsible. You have more options than I had 20 years ago. 20 years ago it was *go* to college. NO on-line, No computers. If someone had a typewriter, they were popular.

    Stop whining, take responsibility and pay your own way. I did and I was 18.

    Shouldn't I sue or steal the money from my mother for not providing me with an education? Same thing? Right?

    Donkey wanted to kick my ass; here is my response:

    Not huh? Interesting...please be sure and tell people like Shunned Father or the Berry Girl or Erica or the scores of others who were hurt or THREATENED with losing their families. As far as wrongfully imprisoned - ever experienced the prison of the mind or physical prison? Ever experienced either for the "truth"?

    Go ahead, rip me a new one for improper grammer and sentence structure.

    Well, let me count....

    My sister--she ran away from home at age 17; I was 14. My mother told her never to come back. Told her she was a whore and a slut and would never make it to the new system. Told her she was throwing her life away on a worldly guy who only wanted to fuck her. Yes, my wonderful, JW mother used language like that. All the time.

    When my sister got pregnant, my mother told her to get married. Sis didn't want to get married. She wanted to come back home. Mom told her she was a whore with a bastard so she could not have her in the house until she was married. Sis got married and mom said you will have to repent and get reinstated. Sis said no.

    Their relationship is still scarred. My sister and I have no relationship. She and her husband moved away and she refused all contact with my mother and I for years. My mother apologized just last year for what she said 25 years ago.

    My mother's family is all JW. Due to my mother's paternal grandparents being JWs from the early 1900s, there is lots of baggage. As a result, there are lots of family fights. All in the name of the WTS. All in the name of *good association*.

    My mother cut off her youngest sister, because she was fornicating, in 1968. Her sister never forgave her. Neither did the other 2. As a result, I have no relationship with 3 aunts and 7 cousins. Or their families.

    Because of the WTS my fathers family wanted nothing to do with us. They were not JWs. We were the nutty ones. We were cut off from them because they were *worldly*.

    So out of a family of 4 immediate aunts, 6 immediate uncles, and 10 first cousins I *know* none of them. They are strangers. All because the WTS created divides that only other JWs understand.

    Was it easy going to college at 18? No. I had no idea what I was doing there. I was supposed to be pioneering and getting married. And having kids.

    I ended up stumbling through it somehow. Am I proud of that. Yes. I earned it. Coming from a family that did not value education, at all, it was graifying to finally graduate. Am I bragging, no. If I can do it, anyone can. Believe me.

    The WTS has fucked up my family in more ways than I can or will document for you. I don't have to prove to you or anyone else the negative effect they have had on my life. I lost my family because of the fucking Watchtower and all their fucked up head games. They took my mother and made her into a Stepford Wife. She cannot think without the Watchtowers approval.

    That is devestating.

    Are you happy? Feel good to know you drew that out? Is that less important or less worthy of money? Of *taking* a million if you could not get caught?

    Prison of the mind is thinking your mother is going to throw you out for being a whore or a slut; all because the WTS said loose conduct was unbecoming. Watching it happen to your older sister is incentive to not do it.

    I have lost all my family over the *truth*.

    I lost just as much as anyone on this board due to the WTS. I have an education. Big deal. I cannot invite my education over for a barbeque or take pics of it to savor years later. I have NO family. Only my JW mother. I talk to her once or twice a week...she tells me about Sister and Brother So and So. We have nothing in common.

    I do not want their money. Period.

    I hope they get taken down. Let the money be used for deprogramming, mental health, training on how to spot a cult and not get caught again, adult education, etc. This should be put into a trust that is treated as a fund for the damaged. BTW, all their assets won't go to far when you think about all the people who will have their hand out.

    NO individual should benefit with a windfall, unless they file an individual lawsuit, and win. I do not believe in this pack mentality of *let't take 'em down and share the wealth."

    It is not going to happen!!!!

  • Simon
    Simon

    We seem to be in a blame culture nowadays - if someone trips up then they think someone somewhere must be responsible and owe them compensation.

    I think it's overdone and we can do it with the WTS.

    We all bare some responsibility for following unquenstioningly some of the things but they also have some responsibility. The type of abuse of power and authority is wrong.

  • Hamas
    Hamas

    It is perfectly acceptable to believe something when you are oblivious to the facts

    However, to continue to believe when faced with these facts is the height of lemminghood.

    - Some wise old dude.

    "When persons are in great danger from a source that they do not suspect or are being misled by those they consider their friends, is it an unkindness to warn them? They may prefer not to believe the warning. They may even resent it. But does that free one from the moral responsibility to give that warning?"

    ( Watchtower January 15th, 1974 p 35 )

  • Gozz
    Gozz
    Blaming the WTBTS for not having kids, not getting an education, etc. is ridiculous. Every court in America, even California, would throw it out.

    Thank you Hamas, for that timely reminder of a quote. They shot themselves in the foot. It is eqaully ridiculous, teenytuck, that you find it ridiculous that anyone would blame the Watchtower Society for not having kids and not getting an education. Would you also blame the dead for adhering to the Blood Doctrine? Were there things you did while a Witness that you'd rather not have done? Were you ever a Witness? I find it appaling that you can self-righteously write what you did; did you see things differently now than when you were a Witness? Or did you not? It is effortlessly easy to forget, once you cross to the other side. There have been victims. And victims of victims. There are perpetrators too. I don't know about every court in America and California, but I know your courts are about law and not justice. And dragging the issue of reparations to the American courts of law sidesteps the issue.

  • maxwell
    maxwell

    I read a book called "The Seven Habits of Highly Effective People" some years ago when I was still a full believing Jehovah's Witness. Usually, I look upon self-help books with a lot of skepticism and I acknowledge those who have those feelings about this particular book. However, when I read the book and even now, I think the attitude conveyed in that book was sound. One of the seven habits was independence. A later habit was interdependence. Basically, the author was saying that a person has to be able to take responsibility for his/her own actions before being able to appreciate what they can do with others. Once you recognize the power you have over your own life, then you can choose who and how you will let others affect your life instead of just floating along letting positive and negative people affect your emotions or your direction in a random fashion. I came away from reading that book feeling that a lot more of what happened to me was within my control. It's a deeply ingrained principle with me. So when I left the JW, I was loathe to blame any missed opportunities or disadvantages I had faced on the religion or my parents. I've been a legal adult since I was 18 and even before that most of what happened to me was directly influenced by my own actions. I have made mistakes and mostly I have myself to blame for any bad things that happen to me. On the other hand, I have also caused many good things to happen to myself. With that knowledge I can go into the future making better decisions for myself and choosing to be with positive people.

  • teenyuck
    teenyuck

    Please read my post. Perhaps I did not word it as eloquently as I could have.

    I was a witness, my family is JW, my mother is JW. Read my quotes above. I lost my whole family because of the god damn WTS.

    Blame all you want. I blame them. There is still a *personal responsibility* factor. Children who are refused blood on the blood doctrine *could/most likely* will die. I am sad. I am sorry for them. They deserve to live. However, the courts in the US, have upheld a parents right to practice their religion. The Seventh Day Adventists don't have anything on the dubs when it comes to medical care.

    As for education; yes the literature clearly encouraged people to preach and not get one. As Pricsa noted in her opening comments, what is stopping people now? If you are out, you can get an education in so many ways.

    My parents and my relatives are all *responsible* for the behaviors that have resulted in a splintered, fractured family, due in large part to the WTS teachings of good behavior. I, as a child, was caught up in the cross fire. I do blame them--my family and the WTS. Since I am an official Apostate, they (family) won't associate with me. Only my mother.

    However, I still don't want their (WTS) money. I do not think they *owe* people an *education* because they were encouraged to pioneer at age 18 rather than college. If I didn't have an education I would not want their money. I got my education like lots of other people in the *world*....I worked, took out loans and got grants. Just like many low to middle income JW kids now would.

    There is a lot of satisfaction in starting and completing something, all on your own. It makes you stronger.

  • Hamas
    Hamas

    I understand totally what you are saying, Teeny.

    ....

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit