Conquering the Watchtower

by DevonMcBride 21 Replies latest jw friends

  • Phantom Stranger
    Phantom Stranger

    Yeah, nice Socrates impression, growed... got any others? :)

    I'm simply stating that working towards a better world and having some success makes a bigger difference than bringing down some crackpot religion and having some other crackpot religion spring up, feeding the same needs that that last one did. I don't think I talked about ultimate perfection or 100% fulfillment - that's the "paradise earth" argument, folks. The objection that not every person can be totally fulfilled isn't a sufficient reason, in my mind, to not work towards a better world.

    So, are you saying that the world isn't more peaceful than it used to be? Are you saying that life on earth isn't more fulfilling than it used to be? If I understand you correctly, you're saying that things can't be universally fulfilling, because peace is impossible, because conflict is inevitable. And no, you're right, sitting on our asses ain't gonna improve the world - so get out there and make a difference. How? You're a responsible adult - you figure it out. I'd rather have someone that disagrees with me about what should be done out there doing something, rather than someone who agrees with me doing squat. And while you are undoubtedly doing something, I am suggesting that your effectiveness will be limited for the reasons already stated.

    BTW, I suggest that if the WTS wasn't emotionally satisfying to its members, they would leave. The fact that they have so many leave shows that they fail a lot of people. You (not "you", growed, just a figure of speech) can talk about lies, coercion, or "mind control" - but the bottom line is that people pay the prices to get the benefits, right up until they decide to stop.

    I've addressed this general topic of anti -WTS action before, here. Probably said it better there than I will here... but that's my position, encapsulated.

    Nice to see you shotgun. I'll probably come and go on some random basis. But I thought Dave was the main source of disruption at the shindig - you're gonna give me a reputation I haven't earned yet :)

  • imallgrowedup
    imallgrowedup

    Phantom -

    I downloaded your thread. I'll get myself a cup of coffee, peruse it, and get back with you.

    growedup

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit