FD and DireStraight,
It really p*sses me off when thin people say "its so simple: eat less"
The fact is that everyone needs a certain amount of food every day. If you go a while without food, you get hungry of course and everyone's appetites vary. Some people are fussy eaters and pick at food, some people love their food and will try anything. Everyone's body is different (including metabolism).
Whilst dieting is just a numbers game (cals burned vs cals eaten) it isn't so easy as to say "eat less". In fact, some people don't eat enough of the right foods on their diets and that is why they don't lose weight.
For instance, I know someone who tried WW but wasn't eating enough of the right foods. On paper, it seemed that she ate very little indeed in terms of portion size. Therefore she had to bulk up her diet with suitable vegetables and very lean meats. You need to consume enough calories to keep your metabolism going or your body might go into "starve" mode and then fail to metabolise calories efficiently if you return to eating a little more (still within normal calorie intake I might add). Add to that any other factors such as drugs which affect weight gain / loss and you've got a lot more to think about.
So "eat less" isn't practical advice for everyone and it minimises other people's genuine struggles with their weight. If it was just a case of saying "oh thanks for saying that, now I know, how silly of me, I should just eat less! DOH!" then you wouldn't see many fat people cos not many people like being fat! If it were that easy they'd follow that simple rule and bob's yer uncle: thin people all over the place and curry houses out of business.
I admit that the individual needs to take control of their weight problem and not try to blame other factors, as Fe203grl said it's all about cals, so the individual needs to learn how to control it. However just flippantly making it sound as though fat people are just gluttons isn't representing the facts.
Also on the subject of excersize, balanced excersize (not necessarily an hour a day, but that would be fine depending upon what you were doing) is appropriate. Fat burning isn't about going 100% all of the time in excersize.
Can you tell this is a pet hate of mine?
Sirona