How about the one where some Witness was watching Bewitched and the same thing that popped up in Samantha Steven's living room, popped up in the Witness' living room. Of course, once she yelled out "Jehovah", it disappeared. Ditto for those that watched I Dream of Jeannie.
Funny, we couldn't watch Bewitched because it had witches, but for some reason I Dream of Jeannie was OK. Maybe my dad liked the costume better...
As far as Michael Jackson being a JW at one time, I think that's more than rumor or legend. I've heard interviews with family members and seen shows that seem to confirm it.
As far as rumors, I remember reading one on this board. It goes something like this: 2 JW kids were at a wordly party and ended up playing with a ouiji board. They asked it if it feared the Jehovah's Witnesses and it replied that it didn't - that they have their children. At which time, the JW kids fled in terror.
I remember stories about one lady at the hall who liked watching scary movies and it was inferred that those were movies about the supernatural. One night, after watching one of these movies, she went to bed and saw the sheets floating above her bed.
I remember one about some JWs who had presumably bought a picture from a yard sale. I think most of the family was out for a drive and somebody was left at the house. They noticed the picture was crooked and when they straightened it, the family was suddenly transported to another town some 60 miles or so away. Needless to say, they got rid of the picture. I think it might have been neat to have when I was a kid. Having a secret party and find out mom and dad are on their way home, straighten the picture and POOF - more time to party!
I vaguely remember something about some posessed tiki doll coming to life. But then again, I remember seeing (recently) a movie from the 70's with the exact same thing. But I'm sure I heard it when I was a kid as something that happened to a JW. At least I know what movie they were getting it from.