What is "Right?"

by Farkel 53 Replies latest jw friends

  • JustAThought
    JustAThought

    Given that the point of this story is mankind's unrighteousness (my take), it is interesting to note that, ... of the righteous people rescued from the conflagration, ...

    ... one had offered his virgin daughters to a sex-crazed mob

    ... another apparently felt pangs of regret over leaving a city where a sex-crazed mob had just threatened the sanctity of her home and loved ones

    ... two others made their father drunk, slept with him, and ultimately bore his children

    It makes you wonder what the rest of the city was like.

    JustAThought

  • lisaBObeesa
    lisaBObeesa

    Dear Farkel,

    You said:

    "I'm really not that interested in discussing whether the Bible is true or not, but I am interested in discussing whether the JW's interpretation of the Bible is true."

    I am really sorry about my JW comment then. I thought the issue was whether or not there was some 'right and wrong' higher than and outside of God in the book of Genesis. And then this sorta led into the question of omniscience.....

    I assumed (sorry!) that we both already were in agreement on the fact that the JW teachings are wrong.

    One sorta off the subject point I would like to make, though, is that a person must throw out EVERYTHING learned as a JW and start from scratch if they wish to investigate the Bible to see what it is about and what it says.

    One little example of this would be how the JWs teach that the OT and the NT are completely in agreement on everything. This is not true. The OT does not talk about going to heaven after death, but the NT does. Since JWs believe the whole Bible is in absolute agreement on all things, they must find 'creative' ways of interpreting it. JWs believe that when they die, some JWs become 'nothing'(OT), AND that some JWs go to heaven (NT). This teaching is wrong and the Bible never teaches this. But they came up with the teaching because of fundamentally not understanding the Bible.

    In light of what you said in the post above, I don't think you will find that webpage I was talking about to be very interesting.

    Peace!
    LisaBobeesa

  • Tina
    Tina

    Hi lisa
    I've been reading farkels work for years now. IMNSHO,I've seen that he can look at the bible from many perspectives.
    HE writes from the jw perspective of seeing the bible because that is his target audience. That's who he's attempting to reach.regards,Tina

  • lisaBObeesa
    lisaBObeesa

    Tina,

    Thanks for the info. I am still new around here, and I only read a few posts, so I don't really have that much to go on. I will edit.

    Thanks,
    LisaBobeesa

  • Tina
    Tina

    No prob lisa and Welcome! to the board :> Tina

  • AGuest
    AGuest

    Hey, Tina-Girl... peace to you, dear one.

    Look, you know I love Farkel as much as you... and HE knows it, too... but D. is back-peddlin' here... and he knows it. You know that if he were in the right, I would be with you in supporting his position. And you know it, too, right, Farkel-y?

    But D. is tried to play two-ends against the middle here... and he lost. He IS mad at God, and not simply at the JW version of God... and one day he will admit that... to himself. When he does, he will begin to 'heal', because in order to admit he is mad at God, he has to first acknowledge that there IS a God... which he's already done that... many times... and then put FAITH in that God... so that he can 'approach' Him and DEAL with the issues. (Psalm 4:4)

    My concern, however, is that if he does NOT deal with his anger he is going to sin with his mouth. And he doesn't want that, Tina. I know he doesn't. Not in the sense that, "Ooh, he don't wanna go there..." but in the sense that he truly, in his heart, doesn't want to. He just doesn't know how to deal with his anger, is all, and sometimes our anger TAKES us places we had no intention of going. I don't know him ALL that well, but I know him well enough know that. Thus, I am asking with all my heart that he receives the 'help' he is asking for... that my Lord reveal himself to him... because I TRULY have 'brotherly affection' for Farkel. And he knows that, too. But his anger... and by default then, his FLESH... is standing in the way.

    D., dear one, you said:

    AGuest stated that Jehovah already knew, so by her own reasoning Jehovah was being deceptive to Abraham, and Jehovah said he hates that sort of thing.

    He wasn't being deceptive, D. All Abraham had to do was listen. But Abraham though he knew better, and so my Father let HIS truth be PROVEN to Abraham. Rather than just say, "Look, Abe, I am God and I KNOW what's going on better'n you so get outta my way"... He condescended to LET Abraham see for himself. The same as you would do for one of YOUR grown children: you can only warn them; but you've got to let THEM make the choice and find out for themselves.

    Put another way, he hold humans up to a higher standard than he holds himself.

    No, dear one. In THIS case, He actually condescended... and raised a human higher than Himself. He allowed His hand to be 'checked', even though He knew the human was in error. And He didn't later come back and say, "See, punk? I TOLD you there was no righteous people. YOU... should'a listened to ME! And now, I'm gonna wipe YOU out for talking back..." or something to that effect, which is what a lot of US do when we're right and our children/spouse or other [loved] one gave us a load of grief thinking THEY were.

    You also said, dear one:

    BTW, Aguest: I'm not the least bit intimidated by your version of God.

    It is not my 'version', D. and you know it. And yes, you are intimidated by both my Father and my Lord. Don't forget, you can hide the truth that's in your heart from ME... and others here... but you can't hide it from them. I'm sorry, dear one, but I have tried to tell you that. That is how I know that it is anger that is standing in your way. That, too, is what is in your heart, and by the spirit of my Father, it has been made known to me. Sorry.

    And...

    With regards to your silly statement that I'm still "stuck" in WT thinking, may I remind you that I don't believe that shit, either.[/QUOTE}

    May I remind YOU that it was YOU who said:

    “But of course, God is going to resurrect them, not resurrect them, resurrect them, not resurrect them, resurrect them, not resurrect them....er, check your latest Watchtower for the newest light on who's gonna be resurrected and who isn't. It's sure to give you the truth on the matter

    You weren’t being sarcastic purely against the WT, Daddy-O. Because YOU know I don’t believe their false teachings and flashing ‘light’ either. Considering how we BOTH supposedly feel about what they teach, this was actually a moot statement; however, it is your INTENT for including it that prompted my reply. THEY taught you that falsehood, not my Lord and certainly not my Father; yet it is HE that you blame.

    I use JW beliefs to show how ridiculous they are.

    My position is stated above.

    [QUOTE] I cannot believe you haven't figured that out about me yet.

    I can’t believe you even refer to them in the manner you did when having an interchange with me. But, indeed, out of the hearts ABUNDANCE… the mouth speaks (or the fingers type, whatever).

    D., please... stop this. I KNOW you are angry... and I know some of why. But it is not BENEFICIAL to you. It will not get you what you want. You cannot stand, fist raised, and challenge God to reveal Himself to you. It doesn't work that way. You have to go in the complete OPPOSITE direction, dear one. Are you listening, D.?

    But please know, that your heart and actions are only proving just how much you ARE of 'Israel'... for the very name 'Israel' MEANS... 'contender with God'. But that contention... COST Israel its place in the Household. Please here what I am saying to you, D., because you are NOT hearing my Lord... no, that's not true... you ARE hearing... but you are not LISTENING. You are letting yourself be like those who Israel who HARDENED their hearts. Please... stop.

    I bid you peace... you know I do... to time indefinite... if you so 'wish' it.

    YOUR servant, friend... and a slave of Christ,

    SJ

  • Farkel
    Farkel

    To all,

    : ... one had offered his virgin daughters to a sex-crazed mob

    Do that today in WatchtowerLand and you will not only be Df'd, but you will go to jail. This also begs another question: Sodom and Gomorrah were GAY cities, right? There is absolutely NO sanction in either the Old OR the New Testaments against pre-marital sex. I challenge ANYONE to prove me wrong. Come on, Brooklyn Pharisees! I challenge YOU, too! If some dummy dares bring up the word "fornication" as a term for pre-marital sex then take the thunder that follows.

    Adultery is not at issue here. Pre-marital sex is the issue I am bringing up.

    Unless the ENTIRE cities of Sodom and Gomorrah were practicing er, "gay" sex then there were at least a few heteros there who were also practicing hetereo-sex. Nonetheless, God smoked them all. If there were NO heteros there, then unless some of the gay population were willing to make the "sacrifice" of making a few kids now-and-then those Cities must have had a very-low birth rate.

    Furthermore, in Abraham's day (to my knowledge) there were NO rules against same-sex-sex. Nor were there any rules against unmarried sex. If I'm wrong, please correct me. If I'm right, then please explain why God wiped out two ENTIRE Cities when they didn't know what rules they were breaking, because God had not yet made those rules?

    -------------------------------

    To Lisa,

    No problems. You are on your way and you're thinking clearly. I like that. If you end up a Scientologist or even (shudder) a Southern Baptist Cultist, that is ok by me. You are THINKING! That's all I care about on this forum.

    -------------------------------------
    To Shelby aka Aguest,

    If God told you to reveal my name as many times as you did, then fuck God. He doesn't give a shit about my parents, especially my Mother who knows I'm active as a JW critic but doesn't know how active I am. Does God know that my Dad is now in a rest home, is on constant oxygen, has just developed pneumonia and will die shortly? I mean REAL shortly.

    Does YOUR God tell you these things, Shelby, or does he just tell you that I'm blaspheming him so you can vilify me and my opinions basedu upon my life experience and what I have learned?

    How can YOUR God explain to me why my Dad is in so much pain, why he is 6' 1" yet won't eat, and when he does, he hurls it? Why he weighs about 140 lbs. now and why his body is eating itself because he won't (or can't) take in any nourishment?

    When he was normal, he was such a hard-working Father, loyal husband for 55 years to his nut-ball wife and my mother and he rarely abused me and my sister. He swatted us a few times, and that was it. No big deal. He became a dub after several decades of fighting it. Mom won. Dad only a few years ago would trapse around neighborhoods alone offering WT SHIT to the folks at the door. He was a beaten man then. Mom won: Dad became another WT Zombie. He's a dying man now, and not ONE dub has rallied around to see him in the hospital. Yet he was fifty YEARS a part of that Cult, mostly in the same area and at least thirty years an active member of that Cult. Where is your precious GOD for HIM now as he is DYING, Shelby.? Your God is a sack of Shit.

    Let him kill me. He ain't doing shit for my Dad. Fuck your God, Shelby. What part of "Fuck your God" do you not understand? If your precious God will mess me up for saying that then I say "DOUBLE Fuck your God," Shelby.

    Next, in the human world those of us who are a little more aware know that if one has a problem then one takes that problem to the one who can do something about it. Bitching to those who cannot do something about it amounts to mere gossip. I have a problem with your God, so I took my problem first to him directly: I told him my problem with him.

    YOU claim that HE gives YOU the answers to my beef with him, and YOU claim that YOU are telling me what HE thinks about what I think and feel? Why won't YOUR God take simple human reasoning and take it to someone who can deal with it, i.e. ME! HE won't and he hasn't. No!

    You claim that only YOU ( and a precious few others ) know what God speaks and you claim that I can have this same gift if only I ask for it. Bullshit! I've asked for it a ton of times. Sincerely. I've begged for that gift. It's all bullshit.

    You are full of bullshit and your fake God is bullshit and all your fake answers from your fake God is all bullshit.

    The facts are this: my Dad is dying and your fake God and your fake answers from your fake God are all bullshit. My Dad is dying. And he WILL die very soon. Your fake God has not/cannot/will not do shit to restore him.

    Fuck your fake God and his fake bullshit and his fake agents like you, Shelby. You are ALL frauds. And all that frauds like you can do is say that "God" is pissed off and me and that I blasphemed. I spit at your impotence and his impotence. My dad is dying and you and your fake God is impotent.

    Farkel

  • lisaBObeesa
    lisaBObeesa

    Dear Farkel,

    You said:

    "No problems. You are on your way and you're thinking clearly. I like that. If you end up a Scientologist or even (shudder) a Southern Baptist Cultist, that is ok by me."

    I say: Surely you jest!! (And then you say, 'I'm not jesting, and don't call me Shirly!' ok, sorry......) It would be a very, VERY cold day in hell when I ever joined one of those Cults. Eeeewwwwww! Yuck! Nasty! God and I have worked things out between us and we have had a good relationship for a while now. No need for an organization, or fundamentalisim, or cults.

    Also, I wanted to say how sorry I am to hear about your father. I don't even know what to say.....what you and your family is going through is so terrible. So much pain. Don't look for the situation to make sense, or to be fair. It isn't. It sucks. I am glad you have friends here who know you and support you, especially at this time. You do know that, right? I hope I can be one of them. Lean on your friends.

    May you have peace,
    LisaBobeesa

  • mommy
    mommy

    Farkel,
    (((((hugs))))) I know.
    wendy

  • Tina
    Tina

    ((((((((((((farkel))))))))))))))) We're here for ya .luv,T

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit