Depends on their risk level.
Pedophiles deserve only ONE chance, unless their first crime has involved a murder, a weapon, or any type of aggravated assault. BECAUSE they can't be rehabilitated, they should be locked up for an enormous amount of time, and only let loose the first time *with* a GPS bracelet, weekly supervision visits, chemical castration, and monitoring by local authorities. *All* parents in their target release neighborhoods should be warned within 5 months, 3 months, and 1 month of their release dates, and a neighborhood hearing with local officials allowed.
Oftentimes, in the heat of national cases like this, we can actually get lost in revenge, anger, and irrationality. In some states, there are no levels of offenders and you are required to register as a sex offender even if you are a hooker or a john, thusly making the term "Sexual Offender" less offensive to the general public.
In one case, at a party, a young teenager jumped off the diving board into a pool naked (drunk, of course) and was classified as a sexual offender because the party hosts' daughter saw him. He is required to register as a sex offender for the rest of his life, even though it was a youthful indiscretion, and did not directly involve physical contact with the victim. He did not even know she was out and about.
The laws need to make allowances for those different levels of offenders and assign risk factors to each. If it (a sexual offence against a child involving sodomy, intercourse, or fondling) happens a second time: harsh, restrictive and severe measures are then warranted. Physical castration, life imprisonment in general prison populations with NO protective custody (subjecting the perp to "inmate judgement") or solitary confinement for a number of years with release into General Population after a required amount of time. The predators will then become the prey.
While I believe child predators are a sick bunch with no chance at rehabilitation, I think that those under the age of 16, or those charged with low-risk offenses, should be handled in a slightly different way.
There have been numerous times that a guy that is 21 will date and have sex with a girl that *says* she is 18, and then find out that she is really 13. Some of these young girls really *do* look 18 sometimes, and they have been proven to lie about it. Then the guy is sitting in jail with harsh penalties hanging over his back because he believed her. Shouldn't the girl also be prosecuted for lying to the person? What can be done to stop cases like this? Some of these girls even have fake ID's. I don't know.. heard alot of stories about cases similar to this.
Lots of complex factors involved in each case, and each one should be taken on its merit, and the appropriate punishment meted out.
Unfortunately, the above scenarios don't cover the case of the Lunsford girl. This man should have been closely monitored by local law enforcement and all parents should have been notified by MAIL, telephone, or whatever means to know that a sex offender was living in their midst. However, since he didn't register when he went 60 miles north of Orlando to his sister's house, he had no intentions of registering with the local police. His intentions were quite obvious. If he had had a GPS bracelet on his ankle, and a probation officer on his ass once or twice a week, this maybe could have been prevented. That, or if they had locked him up for life the second time he was engaged in some indecent and lewd behavior with a child. Bluck.. It's too complicated.
While I am definitely NOT on the side of pedophiles, I am also about fairness and justice. Some people *do* deserve a second chance. If I was arrested for prostituting, I wouldn't want to have to register as a sex offender even after I had been out of it for years and was now working in a respectable job, with kids to raise, and an employer to answer to.
<Gets into fire suit>
Yes, pedophiles *should* be locked up for indeterminate amounts of time, or physically or chemically castrated.. but we're still busy fighting the war in Iraq, the war on drugs, and the wars on each other to really think about the kids..... right?
CG