Would God permit nuclear war?

by JH 34 Replies latest jw friends

  • trevor
    trevor

    This is the danger with believing in a personal controlling God. The responsibility for what mankind does is assumed to rest in the hands of a deity.

    The governments make these weapons and they have control over them. Pretending talk to talk to a personal God may be comforting but it is dangerous because it shifts the responsibility from us as humans. We should be talking to the Governments not God.

    Right now Bush is God. Ask the people in New Orleans who they are asking help from. Bush and his government or God? Reality is a wake up call!




  • funkyderek
    funkyderek
    Ask the people in New Orleans who they are asking help from. Bush and his government or God?

    Funnily enough, God is the only person doing less than Bush for the people of New Orleans!

  • Pole
    Pole

    :By nuclear war, I don't mean 2 bombs like in Japan back in 1945, but something much worse, like half of the population of the US being destroyed in a nuclear conflict.Silly question IMO. It's totalitarian reasoning. Do you really think the hypothetical God could make such distinctions? What's the moral difference between killing 5 people and 10 people? If god has allowed hundreds of millions to die in the most silly ways imaginable, why should he change his mind in this case? In fact a nuclear explosion is not the worst possible way of dying at all.

    It's better to avoid such questions at all if one wants to believe in a personal God with good human-like moral values and any real influence on the material world.
    Pole

  • darkuncle29
    darkuncle29

    This is the danger with believing in a personal controlling God. The responsibility for what mankind does is assumed to rest in the hands of a deity.

    The governments make these weapons and they have control over them. Pretending talk to talk to a personal God may be comforting but it is dangerous because it shifts the responsibility from us as humans. We should be talking to the Governments not God.

    Right now Bush is God. Ask the people in New Orleans who they are asking help from. Bush and his government or God? Reality is a wake up call!

    Yet so many of the Gawd-freaks don't even get this simple concept: It would be a human being pushing the button, not God.

  • Qcmbr
    Qcmbr

    I agree with Trevor on one point.

    If we are to believe that we have free agency then yes God would allow a nuclear war. The critical question is 'would we allow nuclear war?'

    God's 'job' isn't to stop death and destruction - making up responsibilities for God is something that people who want to blame God for their own failings/feelings of helplessness. Passing responsibility onto anyone but themselves is a real problem in society.

    When we kill the last pandas, tigers and elephants it wasn't God who did that, when we wreck the environment with pollution that's not God's doing, when we ignore the majority of instructions in the bible and then whinge about our crappy lives that's not God's doing, when we vote for politicians who are as corrupt as we are that's not God's fault, when we invent nuclear bombs and drop them on each other that isn't God's fault either.

    Until we stop looking to the heavens for some divine intervention to sort out our mess we aren't going to solve anything. If we want to graduate from the school of life we have start being responsible for our own lives. If you hate the idea of nuclear war, vote for anti-war representatives, join Greenpeace, do all you can in your community to avoid inflaming nationalistic feelings and hate and then for good measure get yourself an evacuation plan and food storage in case the worst happens and your not at ground zero.

    I've seen miracles happen but they always came when people were acting for themselves and doing something about their life. Its far easier for God to steer your course when your moving than when your sat on your pooper.

  • stillajwexelder
    stillajwexelder

    why did he not stop the Black Death in the middle ages which destroyed a huge % of the earths population - of coursevhe will allow nuclear war

  • tetrapod.sapien
    tetrapod.sapien

    because, god has no power over viruses, as they are not truly living things.

    da debil must have made it.

  • upside/down
    upside/down

    We already had a nuclear war (ok battle..) and two cities were destroyed and tens of thousands instantly vaporized...

    "God" didn't even blink...

    Face it people...we're on our own...have been from day one.

    u/d

  • confusedjw
    confusedjw

    Why not? He lets children suffer.

  • Undecided
    Undecided
    Good point defd. It again comes down to free will.

    Yes we have plenty of free will to kill and die but where is the free will to live happily without disease and old age and death???

    Ken P.

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit