Yes and no.
Yes I was shocked when some "unspiritual" brother was chosen by the obviously blind holy spirit.
No I wasn't shocked because the main criteria for appointment appeared to be "do we like him" and "who are they related to."
Nepotism and favouritism was rife in every cong I was ever in.
I would also add "is he a successful business man or professional" to that list of criteria because that seemed to impress most elders also.