"why not allow those who wish to stay JW's to stay in peace, without critism and why not allow those who wish to leave simply leave" .
How about this, why don't they friggin' stop knocking our doors early in the Morning on Saturdays to sell their religious rubbish?
Or how about this, why don't they stop looking for recruits and just let the recruits come to them instead? In other words, let the people come to the KH by themselves rather than the JWs come to the people?
(6) To what extent are both sides willing to accept responsibility for their own decisions? It is easy to cry mental manipulation, brainwashing, etc, but in reality such a paradigm could hardly account for millions of people subscribing to this or that belief system. It would seem that people who believe the Watchtower (or any other religious or non-religious tenets) do so because they have CHOSEN to believe it; people who don't believe it have CHOSEN not to believe it. That is not to say that such choices are always made consciously; many are made by default. But would you agree that there is a strong tendency in both camps to say that the problem is all "out there," with the other side? How realistic is such a position?
Does the factor of FEAR plays a part in choosing to believe the Watchtower or staying in it? When you choose NOT to believe it, you will run into the FEAR of being shunned, don't you? One side, the JW side, will never accept responsibility because they always think that they are right and anything against it is evil. That will be their thinking and they will never look at the other side of the story. exJWs tend to have a more realistic position than JWs because JWs live within their own little world or truth while exJWs already lived in that world and are thriving as well as living in the real world.
Now, I also like to see your answers to your questions.