Here is what I find reprehensible.
Prior to 1935 it was believed that all Witnesses ("Bible Students" as they were then known) were going to go to heaven, correct? There was only the one class of Christians all with the heavenly hope. Then in 1935 the teaching changed into 2 hopes, 1 heavenly, 1 earthly. Further it was taught that everyone who came into association with the Organization after 1935 was generally going to live on earth, not in heaven. Now in 2008 the 1935 change has effectively been removed. So, wouldn't that mean that, if nothing changed in 1935, that all Witnesses would go to heaven?
Either 1935 was right or it was wrong, and if it was wrong then it would seem that their former teaching, that of one class of Christians all going to heaven, would still be in effect. Am I missing something here?
So why is it that they don't teach that all Witnesses are anointed and go to heaven? They want to uncouple themselves from the failed 1935 teaching but they don't want to go all the way and recognize that the whole 2 classes of Christians teaching is wrong as well. They are too tied in with the idea of 144,000 being a literal number of persons going to heaven. Thus, they say that the 1935 cut-off may have been wrong.
Well if it was then what caused so many Witnesses, back in 1935 and 1936, to suddenly start believing that they were going to live on earth rather than in heaven? If the Watchtower didn't have the right to tell people that they weren't going to heaven and they told them that anyway wouldn't that be something like what is described at Matthew 23:13- "But woe to you, scribes and Pharisees, hypocrites, because you shut off the kingdom of heaven from people; for you do not enter in yourselves, nor do you allow those who are entering to go in."
Pretty serious situation the Watchtower Society finds themselves in if they are behaving like Pharisees.