My parents never told me about the Santa Myth. Being raised JW, I came home from preschool one day laughing and said to my mom "You're never going to believe this. They told me at school there's some fat guy in a red suit who gives presents to all the kids in the whole world in one night."
Even at 3 I was a skeptic LOL.
We started celebrating when my daughter was turning 4. I told her that a lot of parents tell their kids about Santa as if he were real, but that Christmas presents really come from the hard work of people who love you. I also taught her that generosity is the best lesson in the Santa belief and that is a lesson everyone should learn; give all you can, and give often.
She still has plenty of magical thinking and belief in fairy tales without the Santa myth. I hope you guys can come to an agreement on this...one that you can both live with. Ah, the joys of parenting are many, varied and splendered LOL.
hugs
essie