I'm not so arrogant to think that we deserve an answer from God when we demand it.
Andi, I don't think that it's arrogant to believe that if a being is going to accept the worship and sacrifice, even to the point of dying in many cases, of the other child-like beings who worship them (if god is superior to us) that they should give some kind of frame of reference, or meaning of life, if you will, to those doing the worshipping. Or some form of protection. If you're going to go by the Bible, god did it before, why not do it again?
I will just leave it at this; that I respect everyone's beliefs, but that I don't like to discuss god/philosophy. I guess the dubs beat that desire out of me. nor do i want to convince anyone else that they shouldn't believe. its a conclusion that each person has to come to on their own, this is why i don't believe in preaching. yes i think that discussion is key and tolerance, on all sides of the religious issues in the world would make the planet more habitable. it just doesn't work out often that discussion betters the situation much.
If there is no God, why do so many become upset when disasters and death occur? Why blame someone who doesn't exist? And why demand from believers an explanation, when you have none better to offer?
Never did I blame god, that is what gets me the most about the believers in this thread! They keep saying that the non-believers are blaming god. Well speaking as a strong doubter/near total nonbeliever, all I can say is that
I don't believe that god caused it,
I don't believe god could have prevented it, I
don't believe that god chose some to live and some to die, because I don't believe in god at all. Why am I upset that disasters occur?
Because thousands of people died! That's upsetting to any human with a shred of heart and soul in them. That's why. I don't have all the answers and I didn't expect anyone else to either; but you know what really gets under my skin is when people say "i don't have all the answers" but then go on to quote what could be coming straight from the Borg cliche's about god having a greater purpose, all of that. it's like you say on the surface "i don't have all the answers' but deep down, you really do believe you do, otherwise you wouldn't feel the need to convince anyone else. You wouldn't need to explain to me why you believe. You'd be happy to say "I believe in God" and leave it at that. I used to believe. I believed with the best of them. I believed with the heart of a child believing that the world is safe and people can be trusted. But then, I grew up and realized that belief system does not work for me. It takes my power away, it places the ultimate fate of what happens in my life out of my hands and into a set of hands that cannot be trusted or counted upon to even give reasons why things are the way they are. That does not work for me. You may think that its strange that I hang out here if I don't want to discuss god. But there are enough viewpoints here that make it possible for me to do so. I don't hang out in any other religious forums for the sake of discussing religion, like I said before, I guess I'm all 'religioned" out. I don't understand why some get defensive (please notice i said some not all!) . if god is almighty and all knowing, and I'm wrong and he does exist, then I can bet he's not offended that i don' t believe in him. cause i'm just one lowly human of no consequence. it doesn't matter if i live to be 100 or die tomorrow. it matters to no one but the people who may, or may not miss me if i were gone. outside that circle, it means nothing in the grand scheme of things. i think that it would be arrogant to believe that it did. my life is no more important than anyone who got swept away in those torrents of water. yet I live, and they died. there is no sense in that to me. I cannot believe that god has a greater purpose for me than he could have had for any of the children who died in Asia, or who will die in the days to come from the aftermath of this tragedy. g'night all... ~essie p.s. to cyber; oh, i hope your friend is okay. i have ties to that area of the world that i cannot discuss here, but needless to say my family was very lucky, and the people that we have in one of the hardest hit areas have been accounted for, alive thus far.