If you are asking from an JW perspective - (from what I've seen) - a fader/inactive person is better than a da'd/df'd person, based on the treatment toward them by other witnesses. A fader/inactive one is weak - as for a DA person - the shunning treatment experienced is the same - complete and total however, that being said, the witnesses that I know admittedly believe that the DA'd person is more vile than the DF'd person.
I'ts all a lot of crap no matter how you cut it. If a person cannot leave an organization for any reason and remain on good and reasonable terms with friends/family and even the leadership, then the organization is quite obviously a dictatorship run strictly on policy and legalities. It is not a fellowship. It is not a loving nor a kind relationship. It is both repressive and oppressive. It is an abusive connection whereby the WTS retains all the power - controlling by fear, exhaustion, guilt and isolation. swife.