Its so tough Cordy, but ultimately you have to make a decision that many have made on here already. You either carry on living the lie or not, upsetting people in the process. You have to understand that its not neccessarily you dad talking to you in that instance but rather the 'truth'.
The whole idea of the shunning thing is 2-fold. One, the GB dont want the fand and file JW's whats really going on, which they will find out if they speak to DF'd ones and secondly they assume if you miss the contact with friends and family that you will go back (its crazy because they want you to go back for the RIGHT reasons, but they give you what would be considered a WRONG reason to go back!!!)
I was lucky because my dad gradually stopped talking to me, and although i miss him, i truly feel sorry for him.
It is a life changing decision you have to make, to a certain extent, but one you know was coming. If it was me i would bite the bullet and say you are finished with JW's. But thats my situation where i am fortunate enough to have other family out of the 'truth' as well.
You have your boyfriend and daughter, and as soon as your dad leaves tonight you will feel a certain weight off your shoulders. (i did when i posted my DA letter thrut the KH door! It felt like the sun had come out and a huge chorus had sung hallelujah!)
But saying this you know the decision is yours. I think tho, that leaving the JW's behind for good is the one you wont live to regret.
Please let us know how it goes tho...
PaulJ