COMF - serial-killer! Well if he keeps a tidy garden and pays his taxes, that's some good isnt it.
I didn't say serial killer. I said serial rape-murder. Note: "murder" - not "murderer."
Every man or women is capable of anything and we all have good and evil carefully balanced within us, even you Comf, is the point that I was trying to make and by which I stand.
No, that was not your initial statement. I did not speak of a person. I spoke of an activity. You did mention people, true, but only after your statements which prompted my post. Let's look again. You said:
I appreciate that it may puzzle most of you as to how I have been able to be part of and indeed support an arrangement for so long when I have been well aware of its theological and social flaws... Needless to say, I have found in life that nothing is completely good nor completely bad.
Note that you specifically address your support of "an arrangement." It is while speaking of this "arrangement" that you make your claim about good and bad, using the term "nothing" rather than "nobody." So you are speaking at this point about the religion's effects; its activity and the result of that activity. Yes, you do attempt to segue by mental sleight-of-hand from one subject to another by immediately bringing up people:
Some of the most wonderful good hearted people I have met have been JW’s and some of the most spiteful and deceitful that I have rubbed shoulders with have also graced this strange collective edifice. Is this experience any different from any other organization, religion, business, political party, neighborhood, indeed individual? I suspect not.
But it is not the people you are discussing in your initial statement about the "arrangement," and people's benign "arrangements" have no connection with their harmful "arrangements." To adapt your own analogy, a tidy garden does not "carefully balance" serial rape-murder. I like gardens and encourage their cultivation, but am unwilling to allow that every gardener be a serial rape-murderer to balance out his gardening.
COMF