Well I haven't read through the entire postings of this subject but there is definitely one thing that I can agree upon and that is that Borean must be a "troll".
I grew up a JW from an early age and left at 17 when I decided to leave home. I always had questions and always wondered if the "small crowd" the bible talked about was maybe the crowd of people that don't put any one religion or organization ahead of another. That aside, I too question the bible. What I've come to terms with is that the bible has a lot of useful information in it. A lot of common sense though and a lot of that same stuff is used by various other religions/orgs.
Personally, I live by the rule to treat others they way I myself like to be treated. One of the things that I don't like is to e judged and I have found that the JW organization judged me all the time. I had to turn in reports for field service and if it was felt that I didn't do enough, I was talked to about it. The fact alone that I had to track it seemed rediculous. After all, if your actions speak louder than words, and you live under the word of God then wouldn't your report mean that you are active 24/7?
As for Borean (not sure if I'm spelling his name right or not as I'm going by memory) I find it really hard to believe that he is an Elder with the JW's. But then again, the JW's claim to be a united org but yet I found that each congregation has it's own set of rules within it.
I left the organization as I was going through a difficult time with my abusive mother and asked that I be granted some time to sort things out. I was 16 years old and didn't have a home or any possessions. I stayed with an Elder and his wife who I really liked and I found that this Elder was quite liberal in his views much the same as Borean but maybe not THAT liberal as he was still guided with the ORG and had his manual (yes something I found out about recently) to guide him in how to handle certain situations. The thing that disturbed me and actually resulted in my disassociating myself from the organization was that I was the one that was told that I would be on public reproof and disciplined within the org for leaving home when my mother tried to kill me. All the elders in our cong. knew that she was physically abusive as my sister had went to them serveral times before with her injuries ( my sis is 4 yrs older). However, because I had left home and my mother denied what she had done to us as children, I was the one that was being disciplined by them. I received no assistance from anyone in the cong. and was told that I still had to attend all the meetings where my mother was also present and that I had an obligation for field service. When I explained that I wasn't comfortable with that as she was threatening to me and they knew she was a threat and very manipulative, I was told too bad. When I asked for the time away until I could get a home (I was under the protection of Social Services) I was told that that wouldn't be possible and that no matter what, I would have to figure things out on my own and if I didn't attend meetings I would be disfellowshipped because it would APPEAR as though I was involved in some sort of wrong doing. The Elders told me that my sister (who I was staying with at the time) would have to leave me alone and not have anything to do with me. She would not be allowed to talk to me or have any association with me if I chose to take what I considered "a leave of absence" as I would be disfellowshipped, plain and simple. I was told that the only couscelling that I needed was with the Elders and that they would be able to repair things between my mother and I. I was in total shock and disbelief and made the decision right then and there, that I did not want to be part of any organization that would so quickly disown a follower in a time of crisis because they were not putting in their "time". During all this, my mother was the one that received all the support.
I have no hard feelings towards my mother at all. I pitty her because I know she is mentally ill. She is very manipulative and abusive and continues to be so. Her sisters find it very difficult to have anything to do with her but do maintain a distant relationship as their mother (my grandmother) is very old and in a home. I find this very commendable due to my mothers recent actions of physical abuse towards her mother and the fact that she took all her mothers money and spent it on herself. All this and yet my mother maintains a strong standing in the JW organization.
I cannot ever see me going back to that organization. I do believe their basic teachings of right and wrong. And I would like to believe that there will be a paradise. However, I do not believe in any man judging me for my thoughts or my beliefs.
Borean, I would like to know as an Elder, how would you handle the situation that I discribed? The same way as it was handled? What does your manual tell you to do? And if you would handle it different then the JW's are not a united flock as they claim to be (which has already been proved to me time and time again). And if you would handle it the same, then shame on you for allowing such wicked, hateful, greedy people in your organization and allowing a young hurt youth to find their way on their own.
As for me, I am a very strong individual mentally and am very level headed. I am a kind caring person that loves life and loves people. I feel passionate about helping people and making sure that life is as good as it can get.
Treat others as you yourself would like to be treated.... what a great statement to live by.