Nice post. I never had ambitions to be an Elder but was flattered when I was appointed and thought it would give me an opportunity to help the sheep. My first Elders meeting was an eye opener, I was appointed the SO role, after the previous one decided he didn't want to it because it was putting too many miles on his car. The reasons the body felt I would be appropriate was because I had Auxillary Pioneered quite regularly and my wife and I enjoyed the service. I say "enjoyed" the service, the truth is we enjoyed walking in the countryside and we had loads of "calls" who were never going to progress but they would invite us in and provide tea and cakes.
Also at that meeting there was a heated debate about an ongoing JC involving an extremely charming character who had obviously been able to divide the body straight down the middle about a very serious allegation. There didn't seem to be any spirit of cooperation and the stronger personalities always seemed to run out. My feeling was that board meetings were better run and less confrontational. I saw nothing that indicated the operation of Holy spirit.
I will say that since then there have been some very constructive meetings, and some good decisions have been made, but these have been overshadowed by power struggles, campaigning among fellow elders and blatent displays of nepotism, (completely against the direction of unit 4a of the "Pay Attention" book).