Hi Pers,
It's me again with another question.
Let's say that there were some JW's that found something changed at one point in time (new light) that they just couldn't agree with. These people believe in God with all their hearts, but they decided to follow the scripture I quoted to you above, and just couldn't give their conscience over to the GB, and were subsequently either DF'd or they DA'd themselves simply because they could not agree with one article of new light.
Does the fact that these people could not conscientiously follow the organization any longer because they didn't agree with someone mean that they are apostate? Is the loyalty that the organization requires from it's people mean that you MUST not disagree with the organization in any way shape or form? Doing so automatically equates one as an apostate or at least spiritually weak? How can you have free will if that is the view that the organization takes whenever someone disagree's with their current doctrine? After all, these people are by their own as well as your own account, fallable human beings. The only one that is perfect is Jesus, right? So, if these people make mistakes, and some otherwise loyal JW's believe that an interpretation is scriturally wrong or unfounded, and disagree with the GB, how can the GB in good conscience classify them as apostate (for they may be correct, and history shows that on many occasions people were disfellowed for 'running ahead' of the organization only to have the organization later adopt that very view that some were DF'd for in the past) ? For that matter, how can ANYONE classify them as apostate? Aren't you (and the GB) passing judgement on them? Doesn't the bible state that NO-ONE except Jesus/God has the authority to judge? So, by what authority does the organization have the divine right to pass judgement on people and shun them?
( NOTE: I am not nor have I ever been a JW, so I am not an apostate )
Edited by - ItsJustlittleoldme on 17 June 2002 18:35:32
Edited by - ItsJustlittleoldme on 17 June 2002 18:37:28
Edited by - ItsJustlittleoldme on 17 June 2002 18:38:5