Essie,
I think many former JWs on this and other forums ask the same question you bring to the group, but not as elegantly as you. My god Essie, you do have a way with words.
Forums like this help exiting members to not feel alone. We can relate to folks who have been there, and done that. However, your comments go beyond this stage and into the pea soup stage (I just made that one up). Perhaps we all get something different out of coming back while moving on; I don't know.
Do ex-Witnesses have a difficult time making genuine friends in the real world, and as a result, gravitage to places like this? Do ex-Witnesses feel a kinship with the group, and need to touch base like blood relatives? Can other people understand the mind set we used to have, and how it influenced our lives? Perhaps these are some of the reasons that bring us together years after the scene of the crime.
Hopefully, our journey to places like this forum is more of a loose-knit support group and/or a place to let our hair down with folks who understand. A moth gives its life in search of light; hopefully we've found a life after leaving the Tower, and this place understands the celebration.
--JAVA
...counting time at the Coffee Shop