respectful_observer

Joined

• started 28 topics
• posted 1,004 times   see topics posted on
• send a message

Posts by respectful_observer

• 
  22

  Letter Read At Special Talk

  by scotoma in

  1. jw
  2. friends

  the watchtower arranged to have a letter read announcing that elders would now be apponted by circuit overseers.. any elders on this forum know how this will be different from the current arrangement for appointing elders.. it would be nice to see a schematic with boxes showing how it used to be and how it will be in the future..

  1. 
  2. 
  3. 
• 

  respectful_observer

  I'm sure that the COs received a different letter that outlines their process of reviewing and approving appointments. I would not be surprised if behind the scenes the process has actually changed very little. I can imagine that the CO would likely still have to send the names to the branch for a Headquarters background check before he then "appoints" someone after getting the "all clear".

  I suspect the only material change in this whole process is that there is no longer a piece of paper documenting the branch (WTS) being the one to appoint, thereby providing legal insulation to the WTS.
• 
  27

  What if Everyone Demaded Answers About Where the Money is and What it is Used For?

  by TTATTelder in

  1. watchtower
  2. beliefs

  what if right in the middle of rolling out their latest money-grabbing scheme, there was an uprising demanding financial transparency?.

  i thought jehovah was a god of organization and numbers.

  isn't that why we report time and have all these annual reports?.

  1. 
  2. 
  3. 
• 

  respectful_observer

  I'd love to start the following conversation in the service group one morning:

  Me: "So I recently was asked to donate to ______ charity. When I asked what they would do with my contribution, they talked a lot about their global charity work. When I asked how much money was donated every year, they replied that they don't release that information. When I asked for a breakdown of how much they donated to which causes, and what percent stays with the charity for administrative costs, they said they don't release that information. Whe I asked where I could find and read their financial disclosures, they said they don't release those. Can you believe it?!"

  Group: "Wow, I hope you didn't donate!"

  Me: "No, of course not. There's really only one reason you don't disclose that information: you don't want the public to know, for one reason or another. Am I right?"

  Group: "Yes!"

  Me: "Although I second thought, maybe I'm over-reacting. Not all non-profits are willing to release that information, afterall. Take the Watchtower Society, for example. It has never released the type of financial disclosures that most big non-profits do-- contributions, administrative expenses, total assets, etc. I guess I shouldn't be so hard on this charity. The WTS must have a good reason for keeping that information secret, so maybe this charity does too."
• 
  10

  Artificial Blood vs. Artificial Cigarettes (e-cigarettes)

  by RubaDub in

  1. watchtower
  2. beliefs

  disclaimer: this is a rub a dub serious comment (i can only do the serious stuff every so often when i haven't had enough fiber in my diet).. i was in a group with several brothers after the sunday meeting and brought up the new information about the artificial blood.

  only one had heard of it but most thought it was a good idea.. i then mentioned that i guess the new e-cigarettes are a good idea too.

  one mentioned that we don't smoke.

  1. 
  2. 
  3. 
• 

  respectful_observer

  I've had the discussion about e-cigarettes with a few JWs lately, too. Mostly with the same result as you...they quickly change the subject because they know there's absolutely no logic behind prohibiting them.

  As long as JWs are allowed to drink alcohol and injest caffeine, there's no clear logic against e-cigs or eating pot brownies for that matter. As long as it's not causing harm to your physical body, and it's not illegal, what else can they say? Any mention of "addiction" or "mind altering affects" can be easily countered by citing the addictive, and mind-altering, effects of alcohol and caffeine. And we know how much the average JW relies on alcohol and coffee breaks to make it through each day!
• 
  58

  G.B. ARRANGED A MEMORIAL WITHOUT EMBLEMS!

  by The Searcher in

  1. watchtower
  2. beliefs

  weird!.

  http://ilynca.blogspot.co.uk/2014/04/unforgettable-memorial.html?spref=fb.

  1. 
  2. 
  3. 
• 

  respectful_observer

  What I find interesting is this topic was also posted on jwtalk.net several days ago. Total number of replies on that thread? One.

  I'm guessing that's because all the uber-dubs there are freaked out a little. They want to support whatever decision the GB makes, but this one is so far out of left field, they're not sure what to do. They don't want to look like they're mindless lemmings, but they don't want to look like they doubt any decision made by the GB. Hence, the silence.

  http://jwtalk.net/forums/topic/14742-a-missionarys-life-unforgettable-memorial/
• 
  7

  WT response to artificial blood

  by cookiemaster in

  1. watchtower
  2. beliefs

  hey guys !

  here's an interesting piece of news.

  apparently there's an israeli company out there that has managed to produce universally accepted artificial blood with the help of stem cells.

  1. 
  2. 
  3. 
• 

  respectful_observer

  I've been wondering the same thing. It sounds like they're still years away from having it on the market, but when it finally does, the GB will HAVE to rule on the issue. My guess is that it will become a "conscience matter". Honestly, from the GB's and WT Legal's perspective, manufactured blood is the most ideal outcome for them.

  The current blood policy is such a tangle of contridictions, no one can clearly explain or defend it as a whole. The WT will get sued left and right if they ever officially abandon it as a doctrine, so allowing manufactured blood would solve all their problems-- they could continue with the ban on "real" blood, but in reality JWs could accept this manufactured blood by the gallon, if needed.
• 
  39

  A few International Conv instructions (more ways to control)

  by doinmypart in

  1. jw
  2. friends

  a few official instructions jw delegates are being told leading up to the international conventions.

  congregation secretaries are holding conference calls and then relating the instructions to the congregation.. atlanta - do not drive to convention, parking will not be available.

  take public transportation; attendants will be on all public transit and able to assist.. dallas - attendants will be on site at all hotels to make sure delegates leave the hotel at their assigned times and take their assigned route.

  1. 
  2. 
  3. 
• 

  respectful_observer

  Wow.

  Given the fact that these stadiums/cities normally don't have WT-badged attendants running around telling everyone in the hotels, cars, and public transportation where to go and what to do, it must be some type of miracle that these venues in Atlanta, Dallas, and New Orleans manage to host capacity-level sporting events on a weekly basis without descending into Mad Max Thunderdome level of chaos.
• 
  35

  Family of 4 in Miami FL Partakes

  by James Jackson in

  1. jw
  2. friends

  kendall lakes congregation (miami fl usa), partook of the emblems.

  he is an elder(40), his wife and their 2 daughters (21 &19), all 4 are also regular pioneers.

  another 6 pioneers in that congregation partook of the emblems..

  1. 
  2. 
  3. 
• 

  respectful_observer

  Sounds like they might be frequent readers of anointedjw.org
• 
  30

  Memorial Musings

  by undercover in

  1. jw
  2. friends

  a few things noticed in last nights annual, jesus who?

  gathering:.

  1: only one scripture from the gospels was read or cited.

  1. 
  2. 
  3. 
• 

  respectful_observer

  They did read from 1 Corinthians... Right before passing each emblem

  But Corinthians is not part of the gospels... Supposed first hand accounts (if you believe in the Bible) of the apostles who lived along side Jeseus and witnessed his ministry and death.

  Early on in the talk, our speaker directed us to Luke 22:19 and began reading. When he stopped at the end of v. 20, my SO leans over and whispers "Guess he needed to stop before he got the verse about Judas being there", and smiled. Later on when the speaker directed us to the verses to be read while the emblems were passes, my SO leans over again and says "yeah, because why would we want to read it from the Gospels?" and proceeded to look at the Matt - John accounts, while the speaker read from 1 Cor.
• 
  25

  Gerritt Loesch life story .... Total hypocrisy

  by Skinnedsheep in

  1. watchtower
  2. beliefs

  as written in the july 15 2014 wt.

  what gerrit used to believe and teach.... the roman catholic teaching of apostolic succession claims that there is an unbroken succession of popes in a line extending all the way back to the apostle peter.

  (the church misinterprets jesus words that are quoted at matthew 16:18, 19.

  1. 
  2. 
  3. 
• 

  respectful_observer

  How about this part

  When I visited the priest, he could not answer my questions, but he pulled from his shelf a book on Catholic doctrine that dealt with apostolic succession. I took it home, as he suggested, read it, and returned with more questions. Finally the priest, not being able to answer my questions, said: “I cannot convince you, and you cannot convince me. . . . I wish you the best!” He did not want to have any more discussions with me.

  ...or....

  How about this part

  When I visited the priest elder, he could not answer my questions [using just the Bible], but he pulled from his shelf a book on Catholic doctrine Watchtower that dealt with apostolic succession the Overlapping Generations. I took it home, as he suggested, read it, and returned with more questions. Finally the priest elder, not being able to answer my questions, said: “I cannot convince you, and you cannot convince me. . . . I wish you the best let's schedule a Judical Committee Meeting with two more elders to see if you're guilty of apostacy!” He did not want to have any more discussions with me.
• 
  45

  OH NO!! The latest clip for kids on JW.ORG so very wrong!

  by stuckinarut2 in

  1. watchtower
  2. beliefs

  so the latest clip on jw.org for kids is so wrong!.

  it is about the "victory song".

  lets all sing songs about how vengeful and destructive "our loving god" can be...along with cartoonish pictures...... all rejoice at the death of the evil people who used their "god-given free will", then got punished for doing so!.

  1. 
  2. 
  3. 
• 

  respectful_observer

  Hmmm....love how there are only smiling faces shown on screen while legions of soldiers are executed. Oh, and the final battle scene manages to hide all the violent hand-to-hand combat in some type of heavy fog so young JWs can watch it. If it was halfway realistic, it would get the same "'M' for 'Mature'" rating that most violent video games get.

  "Sanitize! Sanitize! Sanatize the King and His Kingdom!"