Posts by ScenicViewer

41

"we don't need holidays as an excuse to give gifts to our children"

by Sour Grapes in

before my mother became a jehovah's witness i remember.

the fun of christmas and opening the beautifully wrapped.

gifts under the christmas tree.

ScenicViewer

@PSacramento,

Thanks for that post. I was not aware there were scholars that viewed Job's day as a birthday. The Living Bible is rendition is great too. This is going into my notes.

Jehovah's Witnesses accept several pagan based practices, such as sending flowers to a funeral, wearing wedding rings, having pinjatas at a party, and wearing pants.

Concerning the pinjata, the Society says,

"A main concern is, not what the practice meant hundreds of years ago, but how it is viewed today in your area." (Awake 9-22-03 p23, 24)

If that good logic can be applied to some pagan practices, why can't it be applied to birthday celebrations and all other pagan based practices as well? Believe it or not, the birthday observances that result in murder are in the minority.

41

"we don't need holidays as an excuse to give gifts to our children"

by Sour Grapes in

before my mother became a jehovah's witness i remember.

the fun of christmas and opening the beautifully wrapped.

gifts under the christmas tree.

ScenicViewer

My wife and I too would wrap gifts for our kids. We avoided holidays, per Watchtower teachings, but we used the last day of school as an event to do the same thing. Showered the kids with wrapped gifts, and let the kids know it was their special day. Really it was no different from a birthday celebration, except the Watchtower didn't condemn it.

we don't need holidays as an excuse to give gifts to our children

This is the loaded language that many Witnesses use. Translated it usually means 'we no longer give gifts to our kids, or to anyone else.'

One can also see a lot of bad things such as desperation, anxiety and depression.

Are you aware of the increase in suicides at this time of year

Have you not noticed the desperation, anxiety, and suicides among Jehovah's Witnesses? It's probably the most depressed Christian religion on earth. I have known way too many Witnesses that attempted or committed suicide. Others struggle greatly to reconcile the harsh disfellowshipping rules with Christian love and kindness, and having to shun children or other family members is too much for many of them.

The point was mentioned that every bright light casts a shadow. Why do Witnesses only see the good in their own light, but the shadow in someone else's light? In a left handed way, I am grateful for such a biased point of view, because it helped me to reach the conclusion that the Watchtower is primarily a religion of manipulation, loaded language, and slanted viewpoints. None of which harmonizes with Bible truth.

77

Heavenly Gates Closed in 1935 Re-opened in 2007

by Alfred in

since 1935, the watchtower had been categorically teaching (for over 6 decades) that the heavenly calling of the 144,000 anointed christians had ceased in 1935. this teaching was especially significant to older jws (especially those who spent much of their lives serving the watchtower as pioneers, elders, missionaries, bethelites, etc.

) because many of these would eventually turn their attention to the aging governing body members and feel a sense of relief knowing that the end was drawing ever so near.

in other words, as more governing body members (who were born before 1935) passed away, the closer they would get to their long-awaited reward of surviving armageddon and living on paradise earth where they would finally hug grass-eating lions near a waterfall while marveling at snow-peaked mountains in the distance.

ScenicViewer

Joepublisher1 said,j

This religion... should be call, "the Revisionists".

Yes. Jehovah's Whitewashers.

18

DOES ANYONE REMEMBER THIS?

by lola-rabbit in

dose anyone remember this issue?

i remember i was 18 when i read this, being a youth myself i put myself in their shoes and i was so sad and angry.

their short lives were stolen.

ScenicViewer

The Watchtower Society proudly advertises the death of it's own people, including children!

...by publishing this information on the cover of Awake!

All the while claiming to have respect for human life.

87

Watchtower STUDY EDITION - Vehicle for Vitriol and REALLY crazy statements?

by punkofnice in

is it me or do i notice that all the weird and hateful cultish statements are now appearing in the 'study edition' washtowels?.

anointed are nuts - august 15, 2011 watchtower (the study edition) pg 22 qfr: memorial partakers.

this is the number.

ScenicViewer

'bait and switch' in H-bomb proportions!

You're thinking on a grand scale...H-bomb proportions. Love it!

87

Watchtower STUDY EDITION - Vehicle for Vitriol and REALLY crazy statements?

by punkofnice in

is it me or do i notice that all the weird and hateful cultish statements are now appearing in the 'study edition' washtowels?.

anointed are nuts - august 15, 2011 watchtower (the study edition) pg 22 qfr: memorial partakers.

this is the number.

ScenicViewer

Cults tend to use two languages to get to people. First they come at you with something that generally makes sense, and if it is a Christian cult, they will use scriptures pointing to something good; a better world, a better life, a good life for your kids, etc.

Then, at some point, the language changes from the initial Bible based references to the deeper language of the cult. With the Watchtower, it's talk of the anointed remnant, two classes of Christians, the way to treat those who disagree (aka apostates), false religion, etc. Often the references are not found in the Bible but everyone seems to act like they are. One language gets you in, the other sucks you down and makes you the cult's property.

When the two versions of the Watchtower started, I wondered how much clearer it could be that the Society is speaking two languages, like a cult, rather than the pure language of truth. What other reason could there possibly be for having two versions of the Watchtower Magazine.

(Zeph 3:9, "For then will I turn to the peoples of a pure language, that they may all call upon the name of Jehovah, to serve him with one consent." American Standard Version)

A pure language should be the aim of a truly Christian religion, not two languages.

15

When were the annointed resurrected to heaven?

by drewcoul in

jw
friends

i have heard that there has been some changes as to what the witnesses teach regarding the resurrection of annointed to spirit life.. what is the current teaching?

is it still that an annointed is resurrected "in the twinkling of an eye" as i was always taught?

i was also taught that this resurrection began in 1918. .

ScenicViewer

@ Talesin

There was no mention or disagreement that the man I knew was not of the 144,000, and I never heard the '1935' date mentioned before I got online. Is this something they came up with in the 80s/90s, or was it around beforehand?

I too knew a Witness in the 70s, who began to partake in her late 20s or early 30s. I think it caused a little silent murmuring, but the general information at the time is that we can't make judgements about who is and isn't anointed so it just became a non-topic of conversation.

The best Society explanation was that new ones would be anointed to replace unfaithful anointed who had died. Still, the extremely young age didn't make sense.

And you are right about the Society being fairly certain, but still a little ambiguous on the topic. Now the Organization has backed away completely from mentioning a date when the 144,000 was 'sealed.' It's no wonder, since that date too (1935) has fallen completely apart.

20

James Beverley's book on Penton's expulsion now on Abebooks

by MrMonroe in

"crisis of allegiance" is a slim, but excellent book written by a professor of religion on the events in lethbridge, alberta, around 1981, that led to the expulsion of jim penton, a jw who believed he was anointed but also happened to think the wts had some doctrines wrong.. it's a great read that ties in quite closely with the campaign to get rid of ray franz, showing the dirty tricks used by the society to rid themselves of someone who dared to question them.

penton was an academic who the society loved when he wrote a book on their human rights legal challenges ... but when he expanded his research and decided to do a book on their history, pow!

they began regarding him with great suspicion.

ScenicViewer

scenic,

:...the Witness that would read his book is rare indeed

That is where you might be wrong. In the years since Jim published that book, I have seen huge numbers of dubs who had their eyes opened because of it.

Gotcha Farkel! Your explanation is so "schororly" . (Now go edit that if you have time.)

20

James Beverley's book on Penton's expulsion now on Abebooks

by MrMonroe in

"crisis of allegiance" is a slim, but excellent book written by a professor of religion on the events in lethbridge, alberta, around 1981, that led to the expulsion of jim penton, a jw who believed he was anointed but also happened to think the wts had some doctrines wrong.. it's a great read that ties in quite closely with the campaign to get rid of ray franz, showing the dirty tricks used by the society to rid themselves of someone who dared to question them.

penton was an academic who the society loved when he wrote a book on their human rights legal challenges ... but when he expanded his research and decided to do a book on their history, pow!

they began regarding him with great suspicion.

ScenicViewer

@ Farkel

I'm a little confused, and wondering where I went wrong in my remarks.

Penton, having once been one of Jehovah's Witnesses, will be viewed as an apostate rebel for leaving the religion.

Is it not true that the ex-Witnesses who left because they disagreed with the Watchtower on issues of teachings and beliefs, are viewed as apostates? Especially when they go public with their criticisms? Isn't Penton one such person?

...the Witness that would read his book is rare indeed

Witnesses are strongly warned not to read literature from 'apostates'. Isn't this true? Maybe there are some reading such literature in secret and I should wise up to that...Is that what you meant by saying I have a lot to learn?

...probably has already seen reasons to have doubts about the rightness of the religion.

Myself, I would not touch anything that the Society had deemed to be apostate until I had noticed double standards in beliefs, and dishonesty on the part of the Society and it's appointed elders. I can imagine other witnesses having developed doubts about the rightness of the religion, then looking elsewhere for answers. But I can't imagine many witnesses who are strong believers taking a look at anything the Society condemns. I never would. Maybe others are different.

Newbie...Yes, new to this forum, but not new to the Watchtower.

So, if you can, please explain more about what you meant when you said I have a lot to learn, based on my brief remark above.

77

Heavenly Gates Closed in 1935 Re-opened in 2007

by Alfred in

since 1935, the watchtower had been categorically teaching (for over 6 decades) that the heavenly calling of the 144,000 anointed christians had ceased in 1935. this teaching was especially significant to older jws (especially those who spent much of their lives serving the watchtower as pioneers, elders, missionaries, bethelites, etc.

) because many of these would eventually turn their attention to the aging governing body members and feel a sense of relief knowing that the end was drawing ever so near.

in other words, as more governing body members (who were born before 1935) passed away, the closer they would get to their long-awaited reward of surviving armageddon and living on paradise earth where they would finally hug grass-eating lions near a waterfall while marveling at snow-peaked mountains in the distance.

ScenicViewer

New Chapter asked, Is there a thread that gives the numbers of partakers throughout the years? Have they increased a great deal?

Going by memory, the lowest number of partakers was in the low 8,000s (not sure what year was actually the lowest, but it was around this number for several years). Now there are over 11,000 partakers.

That's an increase of roughly 3,000 partakers at a time the number should be going down.

And be aware, these partakers are recognized Witnesses in good standing, since disfellowshipped people and strangers are not counted.

Here is a thread...

http://www.jehovahs-witness.net/jw/friends/209085/1/memorial-partakers-for-2010-11-202